British Columbia

Letters to Eddy: Grade 5 students reach out to a B.C. residential school survivor

Eddy Charlie didn't know his message had reached across generations and thousands of kilometers, until a package arrived in the mail from Ontario. 

Kuper Island school survivor Eddy Charlie says students' compassion is "what reconciliation should look like"

After Carole Thompson's Grade 5 class in London, Ont., saw B.C. residential school survivor Eddy Charlie, they wrote him personal letters of support. (Carole Thompson)

Carole Thompson was preparing to teach her Grade 5 class in London, Ont., about Canada's residential school system when she came across a two-minute video on Facebook.

In the video, soft-spoken Victoria resident Eddy Charlie talked about why he promotes Orange Shirt Day to remember the Indigenous children forcibly taken from their homes at a young age. 

"This is one opportunity when everybody can come together to reclaim their identity and their lost traditions," Charlie said. 

"It went straight to my heart," Thompson said. "Immediately, I knew that I needed to share it with my class."

Charlie is a survivor of the notorious Kuper Island Residential School just off the east coast of Vancouver Island, where at least 121 children died between 1896 and its closure in the mid-1970s.

In his public talks and the video promoting Orange Shirt Day in Victoria, Charlie tends to skirt the details of his own residential school experience, though it left him with deep physical and emotional scars.  

London, Ont., teacher Carole Thompson was preparing to teach her Grade 5 students about residential schools when she saw residential B.C. school survivor Eddy Charlie's video about Orange Shirt Day and reconciliation. (Carole Thompson)

Charlie was not aware how far his message of reconciliation had travelled until a month or so later. Kristin Spray, his friend and a co-organizer of local Orange Shirt Day events, met him at a café with a thick package bearing a London, Ont., postmark.

Inside the fat envelope were 25 handwritten letters.

Every child  in the class had written a personal letter to Eddy after seeing his video and discussing the history behind it. 

Some children drew pictures. Many added encouraging words in bold capital letters around the margins, such as BRAVE, WISE, KIND, CARING. 

Every student in the Carole Thompson's Grade 5 class at Riverside Elementary wrote Eddy Charlie a personal letter. (Kristin Spray)

The letters expressed sadness and shock at the horrific treatment of Eddy and others like him. They expressed wishes for his future happiness. Some described their own feelings or fears of discriminatory treatment for their faith or skin colour.

"I was once judged for my skin colour," one boy wrote. "People used to call me brownie. Nobody should be treated that way." 

One girl, who wrote that she is Muslim and wears a hijab, tried to imagine what she would do if school officials cut off her hair. She asked Eddy if he ever thought of escaping the Kuper Island residential school. 

"I would, even if it cost me my life," she said. 

In their letters to Eddy Charlie, students expressed sadness for the pain he experienced as a residential school student and encouraging words and also shared concerns about discrimination because of skin colour or faith. (Kristin Spray)

In late December, Charlie and the students finally connected face to face through a video connection between the London classroom and the CBC studio in Victoria.

The classroom buzzed with excitement before one by one, 22 students took a seat in front of the webcam to read  excerpts of their letters aloud. 

'Your ally'

Each student signed off as "Your ally."

As he listened to the messages in the students' own voices, Charlie was overcome with emotion. 

Kuper Island Residential School survivor Eddy Charlie is overcome with emotion as he listens to students in London, Ont., reading the letters they wrote to him. (Mike McArthur/CBC)

"I think the children taught us a valuable lesson about what reconciliation is, what reconciliation should look like," Charlie said later.

"This is everything that me and Kristin ever dreamed about when we wanted to 'meet community and create awareness' about residential school."

Teacher Thompson thanked Charlie for inspiring her students to learn and talk about residential schools. 

"It made them braver," she said. "They were able to speak their own truth. Times in their lives where they had felt marginalized or judged because of their culture or because of their differences."

The Riverside Grade 5 class has remained in contact with Charlie.

Recently they sent an orange T-shirt covered with encouraging messages. 

We love you Eddy," one message said. 


With files from On the Island