Politics

Retired general Jonathan Vance thought he was 'untouchable,' Maj. Kellie Brennan tells MPs

The woman at the centre of the misconduct case against retired general Jonathan Vance delivered blistering new personal and professional allegations to a House of Commons committee, including that he fathered two of her kids. Vance told CBC News he could not comment on the statements.

Fresh allegations raised about personal life, conduct of Canada's former top soldier

Former chief of defence staff Jonathan Vance is currently under investigation by the Canadian Forces National Investigation Service over claims of an inappropriate relationship and a separate allegation of a racy email sent to a subordinate. He told Global News he denies the claims. (Justin Tang/Canadian Press)

The woman at the centre of the sexual misconduct case against the country's former top military commander delivered bombshell testimony to a House of Commons committee late Thursday, making fresh allegations about the personal life and conduct of retired general Jonathan Vance.

Maj. Kellie Brennan, an army staff officer, told the status of women committee the former chief of the defence staff considered himself "untouchable" and that he fathered but does not support two of her children. 

Reached by CBC News, Vance said he could not comment on Brennan's statements made at committee.

Vance has not responded publicly to any of the allegations made against him since they were raised by Global News in early February. 

The former defence chief is facing separate allegations of misconduct involving Brennan and another unidentified woman. Military police are looking into whether his relationship with Brennan, a former subordinate, was inappropriate and contravened military regulation. 

He is also being investigated for apparently sending a racy email almost nine years ago to another woman, who was a junior non-commissioned officer at the time.

WATCH | Maj. Kellie Brennan tells MPs Vance considered himself 'untouchable':

Vance directed subordinate to cover up their relationship

4 years ago
Duration 2:06
A woman who has accused Canada's former top soldier, retired general Jonathan Vance, of sexual misconduct told a parliamentary committee he directed her to cover up their relationship.

In her testimony to the committee Brennan painted a portrait of Vance as a senior leader who acted with impunity, professionally and personally. 

She claimed Vance often told her that he had Defence Minister Harjit Sajjan under his control.

"Those were comments to me personally," she said. "I can't discuss their working relationship. I was not privy to that."

Although, there was some confusion over that portion of her testimony. Brennan said she, Vance and Sajjan all served together in Downsview, a neighbourhood in north Toronto.

Sajjan, a former lieutenant-colonel in the reserves based in Vancouver, told the Commons defence committee a few weeks ago that he had never served in any capacity in Toronto.

By far, the most devastating new allegation involved her claim that Vance was the father of two of her eight children, but refused accountability for them.

"In my experience, in many different areas, the law does not apply to him," Brennan said of the recently retired general. "On a personal note, he fathered two children with me. He's not responsible to pay or to have those children under his responsibility."

Investigation ongoing   

Brennan, who previously went public in a Global News interview, spoke in detail about what information she had handed over to military police, saying she had given them tape recordings and text message conversations with Vance.

She told the four-party committee that she was interviewed over two days by investigators and that she had not initiated the complaint against Vance, but rather that it was filed at the urging of senior army staff.

When the first story broke with allegations of misconduct, Brennan claimed Vance tried to intimidate her into silence and told her to lie to investigators.

Maj. Kellie Brennan, an army staff officer, told the status of women committee that retired general Jonathan Vance often told her that he had Defence Minister Harjit Sajjan under his control. (CBC News)

"It's recorded and the [Canadian Forces National Investigation Service] has all of the recordings of him directing me what to say, what not to say, how to say it, what not to say, what to exclude, how to perjure myself and to lie," she said, adding that, while there was no threat of bodily harm, the impression was left that there "were consequences for not following his orders."

She said there has been little followup from investigators.

"I definitely feel that there will not be justice for me and, in all honesty, that's OK because if my speaking out can change everything for other women to come forward, and to change our policies, that's OK with me," Brennan said.

In earlier testimony Thursday night before the status of women committee, the acting head of military personnel, Maj-Gen. Steve Whalen spoke about how the loss of trust in leadership has been devastating for the military.

"That was reinforced to me when I listened to the testimony on Tuesday," said Whalen, referring to the appearance of four survivors of sexual assault before the committee.

Aviator Emily Tulloch told MPs how she was raped one month into her basic training and then assaulted a second time as she trained to be an aircraft technician.

Whalen was left dismayed.

"I have a daughter who is 22 years old and [who is] considering joining the Canadian Forces. It was like a punch in the gut and I still feel it even right now as I am speaking," he said.

Whalen said he is still processing everything he's learned since the crisis began.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Murray Brewster

Senior reporter, defence and security

Murray Brewster is senior defence writer for CBC News, based in Ottawa. He has covered the Canadian military and foreign policy from Parliament Hill for over a decade. Among other assignments, he spent a total of 15 months on the ground covering the Afghan war for The Canadian Press. Prior to that, he covered defence issues and politics for CP in Nova Scotia for 11 years and was bureau chief for Standard Broadcast News in Ottawa.

Add some “good” to your morning and evening.

Your weekly guide to what you need to know about federal politics and the minority Liberal government. Get the latest news and sharp analysis delivered to your inbox every Sunday morning.

...

The next issue of Minority Report will soon be in your inbox.

Discover all CBC newsletters in the Subscription Centre.opens new window

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Google Terms of Service apply.