World

Relief, sadness for families of Palestinians freed from Israeli prisons in Gaza hostage deal

For the families of Palestinian detainees freed by Israel under a hostage deal reached with the Islamist group Hamas, Friday brought relief tinged with sadness at the fighting that is set to continue in Gaza after a four-day truce expires.

24 Palestinian women, 15 teens released in hostage exchange with Israel

Two women hug each indoors at a home.
Marah Bakir, right, who was released from an Israeli prison, is welcomed at her family home in the occupied East Jerusalem neighbourhood of Beit Hanina on Friday. Bakir is part of the first group of 39 Palestinian women and minors who were freed in exchange for the release of Israeli hostages being held in Gaza by militant group Hamas. (Mahmoud Illean/The Associated Press)

For the families of Palestinian detainees freed by Israel under a hostage deal reached with the Islamist group Hamas, Friday brought relief tinged with sadness at the fighting that is set to continue in Gaza after the expiry of a four-day truce.

Thirty-nine Palestinians — 24 women and 15 minors held in Israeli prisons on various charges — were freed under an accord brokered by Qatar that also saw the release of 13 Israeli hostages among the 240 seized by Hamas gunmen during their assault on Israel on Oct. 7.

In at least three cases, before the Palestinians being held in Israeli prisons were released, Israeli police raided their families' homes in Jerusalem, witnesses said. Israeli police declined to comment.

"There is no real joy, even this little joy we feel as we wait," said Sawsan Bakir, the mother of 24-year-old Palestinian Marah Bakir, who was jailed for eight years on knife and assault charges in 2015. Israeli police were seen raiding her Jerusalem home before her daughter was released.

"We are still afraid to feel happy, and at the same time, we do not have it in us to be happy due to what is happening in Gaza," she said.

In all, 50 hostages in Gaza and 150 detainees in Israel are expected to be freed during a four-day truce. Israel has said the ceasefire could be extended if Hamas continues to release hostages at a rate of at least 10 per day.

Ten Thai citizens and one from the Philippines who have been held hostage in Gaza since last month were also released on Friday. Qatar's Foreign Affairs Ministry said that development involving the Asian hostages was separate from the numbers agreed to in the truce between Israel and Hamas, which was mediated by the United States, Egypt and Qatar.

WATCH | Celebration as Palestinian detainees freed in truce agreement with Israel:

Celebration as Palestinian detainees freed in truce agreement with Israel

1 year ago
Duration 1:01
Near Ofer Prison in the West Bank, a freed Palestinian detainee and the mother of a freed child detainee reacted to their release as part of a temporary truce agreement between Israel and Hamas. 'The female prisoners await relief. The female prisoners are in agony,' said Hanan Al-Barghouti, who was part of the first group of 39 Palestinians detainees to be released.

In Beitunia, a city near Ramallah in the occupied West Bank, a large crowd, mostly of young men, greeted freed detainees by cheering, honking car horns and marching in the street carrying Palestinian flags.

Some in the crowd also carried the flag of the Hamas militant group that rules blockaded Gaza and chanted in support of Abu Ubaida, the spokesperson of the group's armed wing.

"I can't express how I feel. Thank God," said 17-year-old Laith Othman, who was detained earlier this year on suspicion of throwing an incendiary device and released on Friday. "The situation inside [the Israeli prison] is very difficult," he said as he was carried along the street on someone's shoulders.

A young smiling Palestinian on a man's shoulder surrounded by a crowd after he's released from an Israeli military prison.
Palestinian teenager Laith Othman is carried by a crowd after he was released from Israel's Ofer military prison on Friday night. (Ammar Awad/Reuters)

Israeli commanders have vowed to free all of the hostages as they prepare to pursue the campaign in Gaza launched in the wake of the Hamas attack, in which 1,200 Israelis and foreigners were killed, according to Israeli tallies.

More than 14,000 Palestinians have been killed in the Israeli bombardment of Gaza and the ground operation launched last month, according to the territory's Hamas-run Health Ministry.

Israel's military says it is preparing for the next stage of the operation once the truce ends.

Ismail Shaheen, speaking from the Dheisheh refugee camp in Bethlehem, said he was waiting to see his daughter, Fatima, who was arrested earlier this year, accused of an attempted stabbing.

The 32-year-old computer scientist, who has a five-year-old daughter, was shot during her arrest. Shaheen said he was surprised to see his daughter in a wheelchair when he was first allowed to visit her in prison, months after she was detained.

"Thank God she was released in this exchange deal," he said. "We were happy that she was going to be released but only slightly so, because we cannot ignore the dire conditions of our brothers in Gaza, where thousands have been killed."

WATCH | Temporary truce brings brief relief for people in Gaza:

CBC's Briar Stewart recaps Friday's hostage release and the effect of 'break in fighting'

1 year ago
Duration 4:42
CBC's Hannah Thibedeau discusses Friday's exchange of Hamas hostages for Palestinians held in Israeli prisons with foreign correspondent Briar Stewart. The exchange is seen as a success and, although only three more days remain in the current agreement between the Israeli government and Hamas, there is hope for an extension of the truce to as many as 10 days. The 'break in fighting' has been a relief for Gazans who can move about without fear of bombardment while essential supplies flow into the territory.

Families left waiting for loved ones' release

The long wait is not over for many other Palestinian families who were hoping their loved ones would be released on Friday.

Ibrahim Awwad's daughter, Nourhan, is on the list of Palestinians who may be released from Israeli prisons as part of the exchange agreement.

He hasn't seen her since 2015, when she was 16 years old, when Israeli authorities arrested her in connection with a stabbing attack at an Israeli checkpoint.

According to the Palestinian Prisoners Solidarity Network, she was convicted and sentenced to 13.5 years in prison.

A guard wearing a neon yellow vest and holding an long gun stand in front of a bus at a checkpoint at night.
An Israeli prison transport vehicle carries Palestinians released by the Israeli authorities from Ofer military prison near Jerusalem on Friday. (Mahmoud Illean/The Associated Press)

Awwad spoke to CBC News in the Qalandiya refugee camp, in the occupied West Bank, prior to Israel's release of Palestinian detainees on Friday evening.

He said he'll be relieved when she comes home, but it won't be a celebration.

"We decided not to celebrate because of the circumstances, because of the war," he said.
"But there should be some rejoicing. There should be some happiness at the return of this child."

Awwad said he gives credit for her release to Palestinian resistance factions, though he did not name one specific group.

"We've had prisoners in Israeli jails for the last 40 years. Some of their people have been hostages just for the last 40 days, and the whole world is talking about them," he told CBC News senior international correspondent Margaret Evans.

"We have the right, just like them, to free our people. We have mothers just like them; we have families just like them."

WATCH | Crucial days ahead as Israel-Hamas temporary truce takes hold:

How the Israel-Hamas truce might play out

1 year ago
Duration 5:36
As the Israel-Hamas temporary truce takes effect, Munk School of Global Affairs and Public Policy founding director Janice Stein assesses how the crucial days ahead might play out.

With files from CBC News