Silver nanoparticle use spurs U.S. consumer database

The antibacterial superpowers of silver nanoparticles have landed them in household products ranging from self-sanitizing toothbrushes and washing machines to mold- and bacteria-resistant stuffed toys and underwear.

These microscopic particles have become ubiquitous, but some are also questioning their risks. As a result, a U.S. research group has launched a public database to help people identify products containing silver and other nanoparticles.

Many manufacturers have touted the antibacterial benefits of these microscopic pieces of silver, but the potential health and environmental risks are lesser known.

“We don’t really understand very well what can happen to people when they get exposed to high doses of silver nanoparticles,” said Nina Quadros, associate director of the Virginia Tech Center for Sustainable Nanotechnology.

If you inhale silver nanoparticles, they’re definitely bad for you.- Nina Quadros, Virginia Tech Center for Sustainable Nanotechnology

Material such as silver nanoparticles can have big benefits for hygiene. Quadros said the basis of their antibacterial power is that they destroy the DNA and enzymes inside bacteria, causing the bacteria to die.

Each nanoparticle is about 1/1000th the diameter of a human hair, and it is able to kill both common and drug-resistant microbes.

“The only thing that [distinguishes] a silver nanoparticle from a silver spoon or a silver earring is the fact that it is so, so very small,” said Quadros.

People have used fine particles of silver and other metals since the 16th century for applications such as dyeing stained glass windows or keeping cow’s milk fresh. But it wasn’t until 1974 that a scientist in Tokyo first used the term “nanotechnology,” according to DiscoverNano.org.

In the last 10 years, scientists have taken on the challenge of creating a database on nanomaterials that provides a resource for consumers on the link between specific products and the scientific studies in which they are tested.

On Oct. 28, the Wilson Center, an independent research centre in Washington D.C., released the most comprehensive database of consumer products that self-identify as containing nanomaterials. This inventory currently includes 1,628 consumer products from around the world.

Silver is the most common material in the database, with 383 products listed. Titanium is the second most common, with 179 products listed.

The Nanotechnology Consumer Products Inventory was assembled by scientists working with the Wilson Center, in part to facilitate more informed public policy debates, according to its website.

Quadros, who works with the Wilson Center, said that before this database was put online in 2007, citizens, researchers and policymakers didn’t have a source to check how, and in what consumer products, nanoparticles are used.

Household products containing silver nanoparticles include such items as toothpaste, face creams, medical bandages, disinfectants, kids' plush toys, baby blankets, towels, socks, kitchen utensils and insecticides.

Examining the benefits and risks

This database compiles the known benefits and risks of nanotechnology from the point of view both of manufacturers of nano-tech products and the scientists studying them.

For example, the database contains wording from the makers of the Benny the Bear plush toy, which states,“With the additive of silver nanoparticles, our product has been clinically proven to fight against harmful bacteria, molds and mites.”

On the same web page, you’ll find an excerpt from a research paper that assessed the risks posed by such goods for children: “levels of silver to which children may potentially be exposed during the normal use of these consumer products is predicted to be low.”

​While the human health risks of using silver nanoparticles are not well understood, “if you inhale silver nanoparticles, they’re definitely bad for you,” said Quadros.

In a 2011 study published in the journal Environmental Science and Technology, Quadros found silver nanoparticles in throat sprays that can accumulate over time and cause lung damage.

“Silver is a metal, and it bio-accumulates,” said Quadros. “Your body will release some of the silver, but a lot of it gets deposited on your skin and it can get deposited in many different organs.”

As for environmental risks, silver nanoparticles in waste water runoff can potentially upset the balance of the food web. The Center for Environmental Implications of Nanotechnology website highlights an experiment in which silver nanoparticles in waste water runoff killed a third of the plants and microbes exposed to the liquid.

Todd Kuiken, senior research associate at the Wilson Center’s Science and Technology Innovation Program (STIP), said the new database will help consumers “make up their own mind on the safety or efficiency of a product.”

The Wilson Center intends to use crowdsourcing to keep the database current and accurate.

“We hope scientists, policymakers and citizens will contribute new information to the inventory,” said David Rejeski, director of the Wilson Center’s STIP.

“Broad participation, especially from the scientific community, will help make the inventory more accurate and usable over time."