Thanksgiving and other gatherings: Your COVID-19 questions answered
How to safely (and legally) celebrate indoors or outdoors during the pandemic
The information in this article was current at the time of publishing, but guidelines and advice can change quickly. Check with your local public health unit for the most current guidance, and find the latest COVID-19 news on our website.
We're answering your questions about the pandemic. Send yours to COVID@cbc.ca, and we'll answer as many as we can. We publish a selection of answers online and also put some questions to the experts during The National and on CBC News Network. So far, we've received more than 54,000 emails from all corners of the country.
As COVID-19 cases rise in many provinces, Canadians are wondering how to celebrate Thanksgiving or hold other gatherings safely this fall. Are small dinner parties OK? Can you still have get-togethers outdoors? What if you wear masks and physically distance?
Here's what the experts say.
Can we still celebrate Thanksgiving?
"It's all too likely we won't be gathering for Thanksgiving, said Prime Minister Justin Trudeau while announcing that British Columbia, Ontario and Quebec are in the second wave of COVID-19 on Sept. 23. But he suggested Christmas might still be on the table if we rein in gatherings for now. A day later, Quebec Health Minister Christian Dubé told Quebecers to cancel Thanksgiving plans.
Officials and medical experts have been emphasizing that the large, extended family gatherings with family members from all over are not a good idea this year.
But some say celebrations can still happen — they just need to be different to be safe.
"Now is the time to have your small, local nuclear family together and connect through Zoom, connect through virtual means with the rest of your family in other parts of the country," said Dr. Bonnie Henry, B.C.'s provincial health officer on Sept. 28.
WATCH | Advice about how to safely celebrate Thanksgiving, depending where you live:
What about university students? Should they get tested before coming home for the holidays?
There have been COVID-19 outbreaks at some universities (including institutions in Alberta, Ontario and Quebec). And at least one medical expert said it's probably best if students studying in other cities don't go home for Thanksgiving.
"It's a hard call," said Dr. Matthew Oughton, an infectious disease specialist at McGill University on CBC's Cross Country Checkup.
He said it would be better for families to send care packages to their kids at their schools instead.
Dr. Suzy Hota, an infectious disease specialist at the University Health Network and the University of Toronto, told CBC's The National that there are two reasons not to rely on testing right now:
-
Many provinces have seen a surge in demand for tests and trying to reserve testing for people with symptoms who have definitely been exposed to COVID-19 or are at high risk due to their occupation.
-
Testing isn't always accurate, and whether results are accurate depend heavily on the timing.
She added, "An individual could be incubating a virus, test negative, feel reassured by that and then come home and visit but then go on and develop symptoms and go on to infect others."
WATCH | Are young people less likely to catch COVID-19 and get a severe infection?
But can I still have a small dinner party?
Dr. Isaac Bogoch, an infectious disease physician at the University of Toronto and the University Health Network, recommended against it.
"I think if you don't live under that roof, you shouldn't go into that house," he told The National.
In fact, in the Montreal, Quebec City and Chaudière-Appalaches regions of Quebec, legally you can't visit other people's homes between Oct. 1 and Oct. 28 due to new provincial rules imposed as COVID-19 cases soar in those regions. Police have also been given legal tools to enforce those rules, and violators can get $1,000 fines.
That said, the Quebec government said an individual living alone can visit another person who is also living alone, but it should always be the same person, and the Ontario government said a person living alone can have contact with another household.
While not recommended, legally small gatherings in homes is still allowed in most parts of Canada. But you should check how many people are allowed, as some regions, including Winnipeg and Ontario's Toronto, Ottawa and Peel Region, have recently restricted gathering sizes.
WATCH | Are targeted restrictions enough to keep cases down?
Is it time to rethink our bubble?
Dr. Michael Gardam, medical director of infection prevention and control at Women's College Hospital in Toronto, said the idea still holds. He recommended people "get back to our bubbles and not see people outside of our bubbles."
Bogoch suggested going a step further. "I think at this point in Canada's epidemic, the best thing to do is keep it as small as possible and really restrict our social gatherings to as few people as possible."
But some experts have already warned that for many of us, our bubbles have already burst since more of us are returning to school and work, and it's not a perfect model for this point in the pandemic.
In fact, health officials said bubbles may have contributed to a recent surge in cases in Toronto. People in that city have now been asked to limit all interactions with anyone outside their immediate household — even those who were previously in their bubble. You can read more about that here.
That said, advice around bubbling can vary according to region, so it's best to check with local health authorities for the guidelines where you live.
WATCH | Workplace, private gatherings source of many new COVID-19 cases, says specialist:
If we do have a get-together, is outdoors safer?
Yes, Oughton said. Research shows the risk of transmission is lower outdoors, likely because of better ventilation and because it's easier to physically distance.
"If you have the luxury of space and if the weather co-operates, then doing it [gathering] outdoors or at least as much of it outdoors as you can would certainly be preferable," Oughton said.
WATCH | Thanksgiving can still happen but avoid big gathering, says Dr. Bonnie Henry:
If I do have a gathering, what precautions should I take?
While gatherings are generally discouraged by officials and experts at this time, Oughton recommends maintaining physical distancing, wearing masks if you're in a place where physical distancing is unpredictable or impossible and washing your hands frequently. He said opening windows to get a cross breeze can also help improve air circulation but doesn't replace other measures.
In a previous article, medical experts also suggested avoiding common serving bowls and warned that the risk also increases when you:
- Invite more people.
- Invite people from more households.
- Spend longer periods of time in close contact.
Will an air purifier make gathering indoors safer?
Pat D. of Toronto wanted to know if adding an "expensive" air purifier would make it safer for potential guests to attend Thanksgiving and Christmas dinners.
In theory, they should help, as they pull air through filters to trap viruses and could reduce transmission from small droplets and aerosols, Dr. Zain Chagla, medical director of infection control at St. Joseph's Healthcare in Hamilton, said in an email.
But there's no hard evidence yet that they do, as no randomized controlled trials have been done to test their effectiveness against the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, University of Ottawa Raywat Deonandan previously noted.
If air purifiers do help, "they are by no means perfect," Chagla said.
He said that on airplanes where similar systems are in place, people have still been infected, especially when masks aren't used. And air purifiers only have an impact if you're in the area near them.
"They also need to be working perfectly and may give a false sense of security," he said. "Bottom line — it's a whole lot cheaper and easier to a) not do the gathering [or] b) throw on a few more layers — much cheaper than an air purifier — and do the gathering outdoors."
And, of course, experts said air purifiers are no substitute for other measures, such as physical distancing and masking.
WATCH | Are daily infection numbers the right focus?
Is it OK to visit relatives in areas where the incidence of COVID-19 is low?
Bogoch warned against complacency in areas without current outbreaks.
"This is a very contagious illness. It doesn't stay restricted to one age group for long. It doesn't stay restricted to one geographic location for long."
Oughton advised against visitors travelling between areas with and without active COVID-19 outbreaks, such as city dwellers visiting rural areas where access to health care may be more limited.
"They're worried about being overrun by a sudden surge in cases."
He suggested sending wishes to relatives by phone or over the internet and waiting until things are more under control before going for a visit.
WATCH | Quebec's red zones shut down for 28 days to slow COVID-19 spread:
Is it still OK to eat at a restaurant?
In Quebec's red zones, dining in at restaurants is temporarily banned, but it's still allowed everywhere else.
That said, indoor restaurants are considered by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention as high-risk settings and may be helping drive transmission, University of Toronto epidemiologist Dr. David Fisman noted on CBC's The Dose.
"We know [this virus] likes closed, close and crowded spaces," he said. Not only are restaurants places where you're sitting close to other people, he said, but you're often talking, you're interacting with a stranger (the server), and you're not wearing a mask because you can't while eating.
He suggested that dining on a restaurant patio is much safer than indoors.
When evaluating the risk of eating at a restaurant, you should bear in mind that "everyone's risk is not the same," said Chagla on The National.
Older people are at higher risk of complications, so both older people and those in contact with them "should really think about how they are engaging with society and what the downstream effects of that are," he said.
He also suggested that people keep their eye on the progress of the epidemic in their own community.
As the case numbers rise, "the risk of someone [with the virus] coming into those establishments does go up, too."
With files from Marielle Ortanez Torrefranca
