Bill Cosby is too blind to defend himself, defence argues
The Cosby Show star is scheduled to go on trial in June
Bill Cosby's eyesight has deteriorated to the point where he cannot identify his accusers in photographs or otherwise help with his defence, his lawyers said Wednesday as they waged a multipronged effort to get the sexual assault case against the 79-year-old comedian thrown out.
His attorneys also portrayed Cosby as a political pawn who is being prosecuted only because a suburban Philadelphia district attorney used the public furor over the comic to get elected last year.
And they renewed their argument that Cosby's lurid 2005 deposition from a related lawsuit should not admitted at his trial, saying he answered questions under oath only after being assured he would not be charged with a crime.
- Bill Cosby's lawyers press judge to exclude deposition from trial
- Judge wants Bill Cosby sex assault trial to begin by June 5
Cosby leaned back in his chair as his lawyers made their case at the two-day pretrial hearing, which ended with no rulings from the judge and no indication of when he might issue one. Another set of hearings is scheduled for next month
The Cosby Show star once known as America's Dad is scheduled to go on trial in June on charges he drugged and molested Andrea Constand, a former Temple University employee, at his home in 2004. He could get 10 years in prison.
Cosby has said the encounter was consensual. He is free on $1 million bail.
Comedian 'legally blind'
Dozens of additional accusers have come forward, including 13 women whom prosecutors want to call as witnesses at the trial to show that they were drugged and violated in similar fashion. Cosby's lawyers are fighting that strategy.
Defence attorney Angela Agrusa argued that prosecutors unfairly prejudiced Cosby by waiting a decade to charge him. Cosby has memory problems and is also legally blind, according to the defence, which presented a medical report that said he is blind in his right eye and has glaucoma in both eyes.
"Mr. Cosby cannot look at a photograph or any evidence and help his counsel or explain who those people are," Agrusa said.
However, prosecutors said Cosby himself caused the delay by fighting efforts by The Associated Press — in 2006 and again in 2014 — to unseal his testimony in Constand's 2005 lawsuit. Prosecutors said that it was not until a judge unsealed the material last year that they learned that Cosby had admitted to a series of affairs and acknowledged obtaining quaaludes to give to women before sex.
"He had never admitted to using powerful drugs to facilitate sex with women. That's a big deal," Deputy District Attorney Robert Falin said. "In our case, it goes to what exactly did he give to Andrea. ... I think any reasonable prosecutor would have taken another look at the case."
Cosby lawyers attack current DA
Cosby's lawyers have also argued that he sat for the deposition only after then-District Attorney Bruce Castor promised he would never face arrest in the Constand case. Cosby's attorneys are using that supposed promise to try to get the case thrown out or, failing that, to keep the deposition out his trial.
They are also focusing on the campaign between Castor and the current district attorney, Kevin Steele, in last year's election in Montgomery County. Steele ran press releases and TV commercials attacking Castor for not prosecuting Cosby.
Steele made Cosby a "pawn in that election," Agrusa argued.
At another point, Agrusa said: "My client is not a meme. He's a human being. And his rights have been trampled by ego and ambition."
In another clash Wednesday, Steele charged that Cosby's lawyers have put the names of some of his accusers in public documents in an attempt to intimidate them.
Cosby attorney Brian McMonagle ridiculed the allegation and said many of the women were already publicly identified and some had even held news conferences.