Monkeys, kangaroos, camels sold at auction as Ontario mulls legislation

Monkeys, kangaroos and camels are brought into the ring as the auctioneer bellows into his microphone, sharing
interesting tidbits to drum up interest among the few hundred people gathered at a venue northwest of Toronto.

Bids come fast from potential buyers, who include owners of small private zoos as well as individuals looking for an exotic pet.

At one point, two baby alligators, measuring about 30 centimetres long and held in separate plastic containers, become the centre of attention.

"These will grow to 1,000 pounds (453 kilograms) and they will be 13 feet (3.9 metres) long, OK, so they might not fit in your bathtub at home anymore at some point," the auctioneer tells the crowd.

• Public to have its say about use of exotic animals for education in Toronto
• Pet therapy with a twist: Capybara, kinkajou and owls soothe stressed students

Tim Height, the organizer of the semi-annual Tiger Paw Odd & Unusual Auction, then grabs the microphone.

'You need to know your bylaws'

"Something I didn't do, and I slipped up at the start of this auction, but you need to know whether you can keep this stuff in your area," he says. "You need to know your bylaws. A lot of places have bylaws against some exotic animals, so pay attention and know the bylaws."

Height's warning underscores the slowly shifting landscape of regulations on exotics in Ontario, where buying and selling exotics — wild animals taken from their natural habitat or bred in captivity and not native to Canada — is legal.

The province now says it is considering new exotic animal laws.

The government took the first tangible steps toward that goal earlier this week, when bureaucrats met with academics to discuss the state of general animal welfare laws in the province.

A spokesman for Community Safety and Correctional Services Minister Marie-France Lalonde called the two-day meeting "an important milestone."

"(It) has provided the ministry with important insights that will inform its work with key partners in the coming months to
determine the appropriate course of action related to exotic animals," Dorijan Najdovski said in an email.

Province looking into regulating exotic animals sales

The province is looking at regulating the sale, trade and ownership of exotic animals, he said.

Some meeting participants said there was much discussion about Ontario moving to a so-called positive list, where only a small number of animals are allowed — usually domestic animals such as cats and dogs. Many jurisdictions have prohibited animals lists, but activists argue those are hard to enforce.

Exotic animals have become increasingly popular in recent years and, according to the World Wildlife Fund, wildlife is now the fourth largest illegal trade after drugs, counterfeit money and human trafficking, and valued at roughly US$19 billion per year globally.

Height — who also runs Tiger Paw Exotics, a mobile zoo that offers animals for fairs, demonstrations and film shoots said he was worried about any potential provincial legislation.

"They're not going to regulate... Our government doesn't regulate, they ban," he said in an interview. "How much trouble do exotic animals cause, really? We're easy targets because exotic animal owners are such a small percentage of the population."

Height acknowledged a few high-profile examples of exotic animal ownership gone wrong: a woman killed by a captive tiger in British Columbia, two young brothers strangled by a snake in an apartment in New Brunswick and an Ontario man killed by his own pet tiger.

But, he said, "accidents happen sometimes."

"Now the government is just going to make us criminals," he said.

At the auction, where zebras run around an enclosure and snakes coil up in containers, Height shares personal stories about his own family's love for exotics.

Kawartha Lakes passed exotic animals bylaw in February

When a seven-year-old capuchin monkey named George comes on the auction block, Height talks about his daughters.

"My girls really like him," he tells the crowd. "They stop at Subway and they buy two soups, one's for him and one's for them. So they each get a soup, they do all their chores and when they're done, they say 'George go home' and George goes back to his enclosure."

George sells for $5,500. Two Japanese snow macaques, one male and one female, sell for $1,100 each to the same buyer. An adult female camel sells for $16,250.

"Any time you get a camel you can lead, you can charge $1,000 a day," the auctioneer says. "Christmas season, she'll pay for herself."

Among those in the stands is Yasmin Nakhuda, the former owner of Darwin, the Ikea monkey, whose story went viral in December 2012 when it was found wandering outside an Ikea store wearing a shearling coat. The real estate lawyer, formerly of Toronto, lost ownership of the Japanese snow macaque following a 2013 legal battle, but has since moved to Kawartha Lakes, Ont., where she now has her own menagerie — 53 animals in total, mostly exotics.

But she can't add to her collection — City of Kawartha Lakes council passed an exotic animals bylaw in February, which means Nakhuda can't purchase more exotic animals or breed them.

At the last auction in October, Nakhuda bought three ring-tailed lemurs and two sugar gliders.

"I saw this day coming so I did all I could since I moved in to have my dream animals on my little paradise farm," she says.