Thunder Bay

Thunder Bay man pleads with council to keep backyard fence

Good fences make good neighbours, the old saying goes, but one Thunder Bay resident is being told his fence violates the city's bylaws and has to go.

Brian Vic's fence is two feet higher than city bylaws allow

This fence on Elm Street is too high, according to Thunder Bay's bylaws. (Jeff Walters/CBC)

Good fences make good neighbours, the old saying goes, but one Thunder Bay resident is being told his fence violates the city's bylaws and has to go.

Brian Vic received a notice from the city that his fence — at eight feet — is two feet too high.

Vic told Thunder Bay council Monday night that his Elm Street fence is much better looking than the hedge that used to be at the back of his property. The hedge was also twice the height.

The fence, which is built of pressure-treated lumber "hinders nobody's ability to travel down the lane," he said. "It block's no one's view, other than into my backyard. So I'm here today, with my hat in my hand, to humbly request an exemption to keep my fence up as it stands." 

Development Services manager Mark Smith says the city's bylaw is for aesthetic reasons and "not wishing to create a community of palisades."

Vic said his immediate neighbours had no issue with the fence beforehand and he's heard no complaints now that it's up.

Given that information, councillors Rebecca Johnson and Brian McKinnon both said the city should take a closer look at its complaint-based system.

Council will get a report on the fence bylaw — and how to create an exemption — in a few weeks.

Brian Vic told council his neighbours have no issue with the fence. (Jeff Walters/CBC)