Sudbury·New

Police video of alleged assault doesn't tell the whole story: expert

A policing and technology expert says the public shouldn't jump to conclusions about a Sudbury police tape depicting an alleged assault.

Altercation in cells

10 years ago
Duration 1:46
Cameras in the Sudbury Police station caught this on tape during an arrest last June. Tanner Currie is now taking the police to court, claiming excessive force
How is the ever present camera lens affecting the public's view of police? We had a policing expert weigh in with his observations about police videos and how they don't always tell the whole story of what happened.

A policing and technology expert says the public shouldn't jump to conclusions about a Sudbury police tape depicting an alleged assault.

Christopher Schneider, an associate professor at Wilfrid Laurier University in Brantford, Ont., was commenting on the videos that show Tanner Currie being thrown face-first into a Sudbury police station window by Constable Christopher Labreche.

Tanner Currie alleges Const. Christopher Labreche used excessive force against him. (Yvon Theriault/Radio-Canada)
“When these videos are recorded of these circumstances, they're decontextualized and then recontextualized onto the internet maybe in small snippets, for example,” he said.

“In some ways that helps to define the situation as being negative for police and the officer in that circumstance.”

Labreche is now facing an assault charge in connection with the incident.

The Sudbury Police conducted an internal investigation and cleared Labreche of any wrong-doing.

Sudbury police Const. Christopher Labreche appeared in a Greater Sudbury Police Service 2014 promotional video. (GSPS/YouTube)
Schneider said he understands why that could concern some people.

“The argument [police agencies] make is that it makes sense for them to investigate themselves, because they know what it is they're looking for,” he said.

“They're trained to do so, whereas the public are not. And that's been criticized. And I think, in some context, rightfully so.”

Labreche, who remains on active duty, is expected to appear in court in March to face an assault charge in connection with the taped incident.