Saskatchewan

Sask. government decides not to investigate pro-Palestine protest that disrupted legislature

The Saskatchewan Party caucus decided not to pursue the investigation because it would have required significant resources.

NDP critic says decision shows government misrepresented facts

Protesters fill the Saskatchewan legislative building. Dozens of people can be seen around a security desk. Several peace officers are present.
Dozens of protesters fill the entrance to the Saskatchewan Legislative Building as they call for a ceasefire in the Israel-Hamas conflict on Nov. 20. (Jeremy Simes/The Canadian Press)

Saskatchewan legislature members have decided not to investigate the cause of a protest that disrupted the legislative assembly.

Jeremy Harrison, the Saskatchewan Party government house leader, said his caucus decided not to pursue the investigation because it would have required significant resources.

In mid-November, dozens of protesters shouted from the galleries and called for a ceasefire in the Israel-Hamas conflict, halting assembly business for about 40 minutes.

The disruption prompted Harrison to make a motion that would have started an investigation.

He had alleged some Opposition NDP members were involved in orchestrating the protest, an accusation the NDP says is false.

Meara Conway, the NDP's democracy critic, said Harrison's decision not to investigate shows he misrepresented facts.

"What we've seen is a huge about-face from the government house leader, a complete U-turn," Conway said Wednesday.

"He knows that the NDP had nothing to do with this. He knew it wouldn't be the outcome of this investigation."

An Israeli flag hangs from a balcony. A banner featuring a Palestine flag is draped lower on the flagpole.
This Israeli flag was put up in the Saskatchewan Legislature Building after Oct. 7. During the protest on Nov. 20, someone draped a banner with a Palestine flag onto the flagpole. (Adam Hunter/CBC)

Some NDP legislature members said they met with some protesters days before the disruption to hear their concerns, but the party did not organize it or urge them to disrupt proceedings.

The government's move not to investigate came after legislature members met during a committee meeting. Harrison moved a motion to condemn the "organizers and the perpetrators' actions," and to commend security.

The motion also called on the legislative security team to review the disruption and develop a proposal to prevent something similar from happening again.

The motion passed 4-2, with four Saskatchewan Party members voting in favour and two NDP members against.

WATCH | Sask. minister clashes with reporters over his use of 'riot' to describe protest at legislature:  

"What I saw was a riot": Sask. govt. minister argues pro-Palestinian protest in legislature was not peaceful

12 months ago
Duration 2:40
Media challenges government house leader Jeremy Harrison's assertion that a pro-Palestinian protest was a "riot." Legislature security deemed the protestors "peaceful."

Conway said she and another member voted against the motion because, even though they had concerns about the disruption, they did not want to condemn free speech.

She said when protests against masking occurred outside the legislature more than a year ago, the NDP did not try to suppress that speech.

"We worry that the contents of this motion and the approach of this government is further dividing the communities of our province that need to be brought together at a difficult time," Conway said during the meeting.

Harrison said he thought the motion was balanced.

"We literally could have put whatever we so desired into the motion," he said.

"I thought it was quite balanced. I thought it was actually something the NDP might be able to support."

After the disruption, NDP member Jennifer Bowes apologized for liking an Instagram post containing a video of people chanting "from the river to the sea."

The slogan has been a popular refrain among pro-Palestinian protesters raising concerns about the Israel-Hamas war, but some view it as antisemitic.