Saskatchewan

Family of murder-suicide victim Shirley Parkinson issues warning

Shirley Parkinson was killed by her husband one year ago in a brutal murder-suicide near Unity, Sask. The nurse's seven siblings want the Coroner's office to review domestic homicides.

Murder victim's siblings call for review of domestic homicides in Saskatchewan

Siblings speak out

9 years ago
Duration 1:51
The siblings of Shirley Parkinson hope to save lives by sharing their sister's story.

It's been a year since Shirley Parkinson was killed by her husband of 27 years in a murder-suicide that shocked the town of Unity, Sask., and forever changed the lives of her family members.

On the first anniversary of her homicide, Shirley's seven siblings are speaking publicly about their sister's private struggle in a troubled relationship that would ultimately turn deadly.

I even said, if he does something to you, do you want to be buried together?- Mariann Rich, sister of Shirley Parkinson

On Sept.10, 2014, Donald Parkinson bludgeoned his wife to death in her sleep. He then spent hours trying to hide the crime in grisly fashion, according to family, and eventually shot himself when police were called to the acreage.

Shirley's siblings don't want to dwell on how she died, but rather why it happened and whether it could have been prevented. 

Red Flags

"There were warning signs that we didn't realize as big red flags until after," Shirley's sister Mariann Rich said from her home in Edmonton. "Depression, alcoholism, mental health issues of the perpetrator."

They hope to help other families clue into warning signs that they feel they missed or dismissed.

Shirley's siblings are calling for a formal review or inquest, something the coroner's office in Saskatchewan has never done for a domestic homicide.

Always put others first

Shirley grew up on a farm in rural Saskatchewan, the eldest of eight children. She was the quintessential caretaker and homemaker, always putting others first. 
Shirley Parkinson (third from the left) enjoyed annual vacations with her sisters, Mariann (second from the left), Janet and Noreen (Submitted by Mariann Rich)

Even through their tears, her siblings chuckle just remembering Shirley's boisterous laugh.

As a public health nurse in the town of Unity, population 2400, Shirley helped generations of families. She immunized babies, taught sex ed to students and gave flu shots to seniors.

Her husband Donald, originally from England, ran a tractor parts business known as British Tractors on the couple's acreage.

The siblings said Shirley, as a nurse, stayed with her husband to try to help him, even as the emotional abuse escalated.

Depression and alcoholism

While the family is at a loss to pinpoint a trigger, they said Donald changed after both his father and beloved dog died.

He became withdrawn and refused to attend family gatherings.

Over time, he became increasingly isolated and depressed.

He criticized and ridiculed Shirley.

He drank more heavily. His temper became unpredictable and volatile.

Rich, a nurse like her sister, said Shirley could not get Donald to seek treatment for his mental health issues.  
Donald Parkinson killed his wife then shot himself on their acreage near Unity, Saskatchewan. (Facebook)

"Shirley thought she could cope with his illness, thinking she had learned how to not set him off," the siblings wrote in a letter. "She never dreamed that the abuse would escalate to murder."

Rich said she encouraged Shirley to leave her husband.

"I even said, if he does something to you, do you want to be buried together? Because I was trying really hard to make her realize the seriousness of the situation."

The couple wasn't buried together. The siblings couldn't stomach the thought, nor do they utter Donald's name in our interviews.

Safe exit plan

Some of Shirley's siblings believe she was finally leaving Donald when he killed her.

"Women need to know how to plan to get out safely, what the resources are, and most importantly to tell no one when they are planning to leave as it is the most dangerous time," Shirley's siblings write in a letter.

Shirley's brother Alan Hewko and sister Janet Rodriguez both told CBC News they are haunted by missed opportunities to intervene and want to honour their sister by helping others.

Hewko regrets respecting the couple's privacy and convincing himself to be tolerant of strange behaviour. He wishes he had asked Shirley or Donald uncomfortable questions.

Rodriguez gave Shirley literature about support groups, but encourages others to be more assertive in getting their loved ones to see a counsellor or psychologist.

Call for action

The Coroner's office has concluded its investigation into this murder-suicide and did not deem it necessary to make recommendations or call an inquest.

The family says every case warrants review.

Shirley is one of six women murdered in Saskatchewan in the past year, three in murder-suicides and three allegedly by their present or former partner.

"Each case should be examined so that as a society we learn not only the warning signs but begin to understand what is needed in our system to prevent it all together," the siblings write. "No family needs such deep grief and pain."

Here's the letter written by Shirley Parkinson's siblings

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Bonnie Allen

Senior reporter

Bonnie Allen is a senior news reporter for CBC News based in Saskatchewan. She has covered stories from across Canada and around the world, reporting from various African countries for five years. She holds a master's degree in international human rights law from the University of Oxford. You can reach her at bonnie.allen@cbc.ca