PEI

Charlottetown MLA pushes Ottawa for E.I. zoning change

A Charlottetown MLA is wondering why it's taking so long for the federal government in Ottawa to follow through on a commitment made by P.E.I.'s four Liberal MPs during the 2015 election campaign.

Richard Brown says review has 'gone on long enough'

map showing P.E.I. employment insurance zones
The Charlottetown E.I. region, created in 2014, actually stretches all the way to the province's North Shore. The rest of the province is in a separate zone known as the P.E.I. region (Government of Canada)

A Charlottetown MLA is wondering why it's taking so long for the federal government in Ottawa to follow through on a commitment made by P.E.I.'s four Liberal MPs during the 2015 election campaign. 

Charlottetown-Victoria Park MLA Richard Brown was in Ottawa last week meeting with officials and said he was told the issue of changing the province back into one zone for employment insurance purposes is still under review.

"They're going to be getting back to me on what the process is and how long it will take. I'm told it could be up to a year, a year-and-a-half — that's way too long," Brown said.

"This has gone on long enough, we should get this zone changed back to one."

Easier to qualify, more benefits outside capital region

The controversial split that created two zones for employment insurance on P.E.I. took place in 2014 under the Stephen Harper government.

I'll be honest with you I'm frustrated that it's not done yet.—Sean Casey

The split has meant workers who live outside an area designated as the capital region of the province are able to receive more benefits while working fewer hours in order to qualify.

This is because the unemployment rate in the rural region of the province has been five-and-a-half points higher on average than in the Charlottetown area since the split was introduced.

Brown said the two zones continue to be an issue of concern for people who live in the Charlottetown area.

"It's just unfair," Brown said.

"It's people literally living across the street from each other, and are in different zones, work at the same plant in Charlottetown, or the same company in Charlottetown, and two of them are being treated differently."

'No decisions have been made'

P.E.I.’s Environment Minister Richard Brown confirmed the climate action plan his government is preparing to submit for Ottawa’s Sept. 1 deadline will not include a carbon tax. (Randy McAndrew/CBC News)

Brown said it's also made it more difficult for university and college students living in the Charlottetown zone to qualify to receive benefits while going to school, versus students who live in the rural zone.

A report from a parliamentary standing committee last year recommended the two zones be changed back into one.

An email to CBC News from Employment and Social Development Canada stated a review of E.I. boundaries is required every five years.

"As the current boundary review process is still underway, no decisions have been made regarding changes to the 62 EI economic regions."

MP also frustrated with delays

Sean Casey is one of the Island's four Liberal MPs, all of whom pledged to bring about the change during the 2015 election campaign.

"There have been no local issues in this Parliament that have consumed more of my time and effort than this one, so I'll be honest with you I'm frustrated that it's not done yet," Casey said Monday.

"People elected us based on that commitment."

He said one of the reasons it's taken so long is that there's been no separate review of the P.E.I. situation apart from the regular review of all 62 EI regions.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Kerry Campbell

Provincial Affairs Reporter

Kerry Campbell is the provincial affairs reporter for CBC P.E.I., covering politics and the provincial legislature. He can be reached at: kerry.campbell@cbc.ca.