Canada

Sad you missed out on the 'One Ring' card? Here are a few other precious collectibles

There's only one 'One Ring' card, but there are other Canadian-connected collectibles that are just as precious as the one-of-a-kind Lord of the Rings themed Magic: The Gathering card recently pulled by a Toronto collector.

A look at other Canadian-connected collectibles commanding big dollars

A game card with a gold ring and fire, the card is in a case with a label and barcode at the top.
The 'One Ring' is a one-of-a-kind collectible card created for the table-top fantasy game Magic: The Gathering and is expected to fetch $1 million-plus for its Ontario owner. (Professional Sports Authenticator)

There may only be one 'One Ring' card, but as J.R.R. Tolkien wrote, "Oft hope is born when all is forlorn." There are other collectibles that are similarly precious. 

The special, one-of-a-kind card was created for the table-top fantasy game Magic: The Gathering as part of a collection celebrating J.R.R. Tolkien's The Lord of The Rings novels. The card, depicting the all-powerful ring with its gold lettering, was recently found by a retail worker in Toronto who has chosen to remain anonymous.

It could fetch millions of dollars, with one Spanish card reseller offering 2 million euros ($2.89 million Cdn) for the card. 

WATCH | One card to rule them all: 

'One Ring' Magic card worth millions bought in Canada

1 year ago
Duration 1:59
Someone in Toronto has bought a card from the role playing game Magic: The Gathering featuring the 'One Ring' from Lord of the Rings. The one-of-a-kind card could sell for as much as $2 million.

One does not simply walk into a windfall like that every day, but there are other collectibles that have fetched big amounts.

Here are four other Canadian-connected items with eye-popping price tags, just in case you have one of these kicking around.

Prince's disavowed album

Prince ordered more than 500,000 copies of The Black Album destroyed just before the album's planned release in late 1987 after he decided it was "evil," according to online music marketplace Discogs.

The late superstar had initially planned it as a surprise followup to his pop-oriented double album Sign o' the Times, insisting there be no title or name on the cover and no advance promotion. 

Although bootlegs flourished, The Black Album wouldn't get an official release until 1994, when Warner gave it a limited run.

Original copies from the '80s run are exceedingly rare: one sold at auction in February 2018 for about $55,900 Cdn.

A Canadian-made vinyl copy saved by a pressing plant employee sold for more than $30,000.

Prince's Black Album holds the No. 2 and 3 all-time slots on Discogs most-expensive list, behind only Choose Your Weapon, an album by British electronic music producer Scaramanga Silk that has only 20 copies.

A black 33 and a third album with orange lettering on a grey label.
Prince's Black Album is one of the most valuable albums of all time, including at least one Canadian copy. (Recordmecca)

Wayne Gretzky's rookie card

To really cash in on No. 99, you need a card that ranks 100. 

Wayne Gretzky's 1979 O-Pee-Chee rookie card was hockey's first to cost more than $1 million US at auction, back in late 2020, when it fetched $1.29 million. Another of the same card sold the following year for a whopping $3.75 million.

"Gretzky is the greatest of all time," Chris Ivy of Heritage Auctions said after the first sale. "This is his rookie card, and then add onto all that it's O-Pee-Chee, which is the Canadian version, and is highly sought after."

The online auction house said the trading cards, which feature The Great One in his Edmonton Oilers uniform during the team's final World Hockey Association (WHA) season before the franchise joined the NHL, were the two with No. 99 from O-Pee-Chee's 1979 run to receive a perfect "gem mint" score from the Professional Sports Authenticator grading service.

Ivy said it's extremely rare to find a Gretzky rookie card from O-Pee-Chee, which was essentially the Canadian arm of U.S.-based Topps, in perfect condition because of production issues in the late 1970s.

"Ninety per cent of the cards as they came out of the factory wouldn't be considered 'gem mint' by today's grading standards," Ivy said.

The all-time sports card record is held by a mint condition Mickey Mantle baseball card that sold for $12.6 million last summer.

A hockey player in an Edmonton Oilers uniform skates on a slant in an image on a hockey card. The card says, "Wayne Gretzky, C, Edmonton Oilers." The card is in a clear sheath. Above the card a label reads, "1979 O-Pee-Chee, Wayne Gretzky, #18, GEM MT, 10, 50008975"
More than two decades after retiring, Wayne Gretzky set another high-water mark in 2020 when his 1979 O-Pee-Chee rookie card became hockey's first to cost more than $1 million US at auction. (Heritage Auctions/The Canadian Press)

Star Wars Yak Face figurine

May the Yak Face be with you, because he could be worth thousands.

This Kenner action figure from Return of the Jedi was only released in Canada and Australia as the craze for Star Wars was dying down in 1985. The Canadian version has a bilingual backing card.

It's easy to find Yak Face for sale online for hundreds or thousands depending on the condition of its packaging, and U.S. collectibles auctioneer Heritage Auctions says one sold on eBay for $20,000 in 2016.

An alien figurine stands in its clear plastic packaging with a coloured backdrop. There is a coin above his head. The packaging says "Star Wars, The Power of the Force, Special Collectors Coin" in English and French. The logo for Kenner is near the bottom, as well as the character's name: "Yak Face"
An action figure for a Star Wars background character named Yak Face, seen in Return of the Jedi for a fleeting moment, can fetch hundreds or even thousands of dollars. (blog.paxholley.net)

Queen Victoria stamp

A stamp featuring the image of a young Queen Victoria sold for $292,500 Cdn at an Ottawa auction earlier this year. Not bad for 12 cents.

Issued more than 170 years ago in 1851, the auctioned 12-Penny Black stamp was considered to be in pristine condition  — and one of only two known in that condition.

LISTEN | The story behind the rare Queen Victoria stamp: 

Only about 1,450 were sold at the time so it's a rare gem, said Peter MacDonald, the general manager of Sparks Auctions.

MacDonald said hundreds of bidders participated in the sale on Jan. 21, online and from around the world. An "enthusiastic group of bidders" came in person to the Ottawa office, as well, he added.

He said in 2017 the auction house sold a similar stamp that had been attached to this 12-Penny Black stamp on a sheet; it sold for $327,000.

MacDonald said the 12-penny stamp was expensive for its time. He said at today's prices, it would set you back about $16.40.

A black and white stamp with a woman on it.
A 12-Penny Black stamp featuring Queen Victoria that was issued in 1851, was auctioned and sold in Ottawa on Jan. 21, 2023, for $292,500 plus tax. (Submitted by Peter MacDonald)

With files from CBC Calgary, Toronto and Ottawa, and The Canadian Press