Nova Scotia

She wanted to exit an abusive relationship. She ended up being arrested

A Nova Scotia woman who was in an abusive relationship says the deaths of six women in the province in the last three months have left her with feelings of grief, anger and hopelessness. June is sharing her story of intimate partner violence and her experience with the justice system.

Recent deaths of 6 women brings up 'grief and a lot of anger' for Nova Scotia woman

Intimate partner violence survivor shares story amid 6 N.S. deaths

2 days ago
Duration 4:13
The deaths of six women in the last three months have many Nova Scotians wondering how this could happen. Many survivors are reeling, including a woman who came forward to share her story with the CBC's Shaina Luck.

WARNING: This story contains details of intimate partner violence and may affect those who have experienced​ ​​​it or know someone who has.

A Nova Scotia woman who was in an abusive relationship says the deaths of six women in the province in the last three months have left her with feelings of grief, anger and hopelessness.

The woman came forward to CBC News to share her own story of intimate partner violence — and her experience with the justice system that she felt let her down.

For her safety and privacy, CBC agreed to use the pseudonym of June to identify her.

"I really just want to help and add my voice to the calls for action," June said in a recent interview. "I don't see things happening, I don't see the reaction that's necessary to deal with an epidemic-level problem."

And that, she said, "makes me feel a lot of grief and a lot of anger — and hopeless."

A growing feeling of fear

June said the relationship with her ex was "unbelievably great" in the beginning.

"He was showering me with attention, affection, praise," she recalled. "He was reflecting some of the things that I had said I wanted in a partner back at me. He was love-bombing me."

But within six months, June felt something was wrong.

There were heated fights, followed by weeks of reconciliation when she recognized again the caring person she'd fallen in love with.

"I didn't understand, often, what was happening," she said.

"I would sit there and be really confused, like, where and how did we get here, how did this escalate so quickly and why can't this stop?"

WATCH | N.S. communities mourn deaths of women in intimate partner violence cases:

Calls for action after 6 N.S. women killed by partners in 3 months

16 days ago
Duration 2:10
As a community mourns the sixth Nova Scotia woman to be killed by her partner in six months, advocates are calling on the province to implement solutions such as mental health and housing supports to prevent future deaths from domestic violence.

She and her ex entered a cycle of breaking up and getting back together, and he moved into her apartment.

June said she told her ex that some of the things he was doing made her feel afraid, but he didn't stop doing them.

She said he'd follow her around the room and stand over her, shouting. He'd threaten to kill himself if she left, which made her feel responsible for his safety.

A smiling woman in an orange shirt stands next to a man
Corelee (Alisha) Smith and her father, Bradford (Coy) Downey, are seen in an undated photo. The pair were fatally shot on Dec. 31, 2024, hours before the woman's boyfriend was found dead of a self-inflicted gunshot wound. (Facebook)

She said one day she was sitting down while he shouted and gestured in an aggressive way.

"And he was like, 'Well, I would never hit you,' and then he kind of just mimicked hitting me," she said. "But he put his hand past my head and toward the wall instead."

WATCH | Review into domestic killings in N.S. must be followed by 'radical action,' says advocate:

How does Nova Scotia's domestic violence death review committee work?

8 days ago
Duration 2:33
Shortly after the province declared intimate partner violence an epidemic, the province's domestic violence death review committee is about to release its first report. The CBC's Taryn Grant explains the function of the committee and how it's meant to prevent future violence.

June said she eventually asked her ex to move out. But she said he refused to go and trapped her in her apartment, physically standing in the way when she tried to leave.

She said on that night she went to pack up his things, and he grabbed her in a chokehold and threw her backwards onto the bed. The argument continued and she tried to get away.

"In that moment I threw my arms out and I pushed him, to get him away from me," she said. "He was blocking my way. But I did push him. And I stood up and I went to his room to start packing his stuff, because I was done."

June said her ex grabbed her and pushed her into the door frame, trying to keep her from touching his belongings.

A woman with dark hair smiles at the camera.
Nicole Murphy, 49, was killed by her 58-year-old partner in their Yarmouth home on Nov. 1, 2024. (Submitted by Murphy family)

She decided to leave the apartment herself. She said as she left the building he called the police on her, saying she'd pushed him.

Officers arrived and questioned her, but June said she didn't understand what was happening.

"Up until the moment that they started reading me my rights, I thought they were there to help me," she said.

"I didn't understand that they were going to arrest me … and in that moment I felt such betrayal, such shame."

WATCH | Gender-based violence on the rise in Nova Scotia:

New numbers reveal scope of intimate partner violence in N.S.

10 days ago
Duration 2:38
Although progress is being made to address the issue of intimate partner violence, some say it's not enough. Alex Guye has the story.

June told the police her ex was abusive and she'd been defending herself after he grabbed and restrained her. He was also arrested.

She was charged with assault, and he was charged with assault and forcible confinement.

They both went through the court system and signed a peace bond. The charges against both of them were withdrawn by the Crown.

Disappointment with justice system

She said she agreed to sign a peace bond because she felt it was the best option to get out of the situation.

June said she's been left with a deep disappointment in the justice system.

"Once an arrest is made, especially in a domestic violence incident, it's not up to me what happens after that," she said. "As a victim, you're stripped of your voice."

Like many provinces, Nova Scotia has a pro-arrest, pro-charge policy, which means only Crown prosecutors can withdraw charges. Police cannot withdraw charges if asked to do so by the victim.

When this policy was put in place in the 1990s, it was meant to help get convictions to keep victims safer from abusers.

June is critical of the policy.

"It really just felt like it was continuing and perpetuating the exact same thing that the abusive relationship did in taking away my voice, taking away my power, taking away my ability to choose or have control over the situation," she said.

Woman smiles for camera.
Brenda Tatlock-Burke, 59, was killed by her husband, a retired Mountie, on Oct. 18, 2024. (Tara Graham)

CBC asked the provincial Justice Department whether it is having discussions on replacing the mandatory arrest and charging policies with new guidelines, which was a recommendation of the Mass Casualty Commission in 2023.

A department spokesperson said the government is committed to advancing the recommendations.

"Violence is never acceptable," they wrote. "If a crime has been committed, we expect the law to be upheld."

WATCH | Speaking up on her experience with a form of intimate partner violence:

Her intimate images were posted online. She wants people to know it’s abuse

13 days ago
Duration 2:20
Nova Scotian Natalie Brown’s partner posted intimate images of her online without her consent. He was convicted, and she’s speaking out about how her experience is a form of intimate partner violence.

June called on government officials to increase their response to intimate partner violence.

"We deserve better. We deserve more," she said.

"We deserve emergency measures, money, funding, capacity, resources, transparency and communication about what they plan to do."

The province has said it's taking steps, including increasing funding for transition housing for those escaping violent relationships.

June has left the relationship with her ex now and there's no more contact.

Message to other women

She wants other women in similar situations to realize that they are deserving of love and not responsible for being abused.

"I would really like them to know that, though right now they may not like themselves very much or love themselves very much," she said.

"I love them, though I will never see them."


For anyone affected by family or intimate partner violence, there is support available through crisis lines and local support services. ​​If you're in immediate danger or fear for your safety or that of others around you, please call 911.

If you or someone you know is struggling, here's where to get help:

MORE TOP STORIES

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Shaina Luck

Reporter

Shaina Luck is an investigative reporter with CBC Nova Scotia. She has worked with local and network programs including The National and The Fifth Estate. Email: shaina.luck@cbc.ca

Add some “good” to your morning and evening.

Get the latest top stories from across Nova Scotia in your inbox every weekday.

...

The next issue of CBC Nova Scotia newsletter will soon be in your inbox.

Discover all CBC newsletters in the Subscription Centre.opens new window

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Google Terms of Service apply.