Johnny Meeko preyed on students for years, Crown argues
Judge says he will decide his verdict before April
Latest
- Johnny Meeko was found guilty of some, but not all, of the 32 charges in December 2017.
In its closing arguments Thursday, the Crown painted former school teacher Johnny Meeko as a liar and someone who preyed on his students for years.
Meeko, 61, has pleaded not guilty to 32 sex-related charges including assault, sexual assault and sexual interference alleged to have been committed during his decades-long career at Nuiyak Elementary School in Sanikiluaq, Nunavut. He is being tried by a judge alone.
Crown lawyer Amy Porteous delivered the closing arguments before Justice Neil Sharkey at the Nunavut Court of Justice in Iqaluit.
"Your honour should see this case for what it is: a teacher who for years and years preyed on his students who have come before you to tell their accounts of what occurred," Porteous said.
"I submit that their evidence proves the case beyond a reasonable doubt."
In the defence's closing arguments earlier in the week, Meeko's lawyer James Morton called the testimony of some of the nine witnesses fantastic and in some cases "highly implausible."
"The only thing that's fantastical about this trial is Mr. Meeko's self-serving evidence about why he made this confession and this court should reject his evidence in its entirety," Porteous said.
"His credibility, I would submit, is non-existent."
Recanted confession
Following Meeko's arrest by RCMP in Sanikiluaq in 2012, Meeko spoke with three officers about the charges. Five hours of that statement, in which Meeko confesses to the officers he touched his students, was played in court in August.
But during his testimony in the summer, he took it all back, telling court through an interpreter that, "The information is not true. The allegations are not true.
"I've never ever assaulted or did anything to any children all my life."
The defence says it is too dangerous to criminally convict based solely on testimony. It also argues that there might have been an opportunity for potential collusion among witnesses — meaning they may have talked about their allegations against Meeko with each other, especially since Sanikiluaq is a small, isolated community of about 700.
The judge says he will make his decision on the 32 charges before Meeko's next scheduled court date on April 4.
At least two of the witnesses have filed lawsuits seeking compensation from the governments of Nunavut and the Northwest Territories related to this case, represented by lawyer Alan Regel.