NL

Here's what N.L. doctors think could patch up the province's ailing health-care system

Three doctors across the province weigh in on solutions to overcrowded emergency rooms and staff shortages plaguing Newfoundland and Labrador.

Team-based care and a salaried payment model could solve N.L.'s woes, doctors say

Man in blue collared shirt with glasses sits in doctors office.
Dr. Desmond Whalen says emergency rooms are filling up because patients often have nowhere else to turn. (Garrett Barry/CBC)

Dr. Desmond Whalen's emergency room in Grand Falls-Windsor is full to bursting these days.

The doctor says it's a problem of access points. People don't have family physicians and don't live close to a walk-in clinic, so they're showing up to the ER for all manner of ailments.

He's one of a growing chorus of doctors supporting a new health-care model — one they say will keep those emergency rooms running smoothly.

Whalen points to a shortage of health-care workers in Newfoundland and Labrador underpinning long wait times and emergency room closures. That won't be fixed overnight, but Whalen says moving toward a collaborative-care model could ease pressure on the system.

Working in teams, he says, will ease burnout and relieve some of the burden on doctors.

Dr. Shanda Slipp, a family physician in Corner Brook, agrees. Slipp ideally wants a pharmacist in her clinic to prescribe drugs and help guide treatment plans.

"There are so many things [they] can do, potentially better than me," Slipp said.

The way the system's set up now, Slipp would have to pay a pharmacist as a member of her staff. She called the fee-for-service payment model the "biggest barrier" to collaborative care, one that requires a doctor to see every patient who walks in.

Moving toward a salary model would remove that need and free her up to see other patients, she says. 

Dr. Shanda Slipp wants to see the fee-for-service payment model replaced. (Cherie Wheeler/CBC)

That fee-for-service model, and the challenges of running a practice, is also turning away new graduates from primary care, contributing to the doctor shortage.

Scrapping it, she argues, could encourage newly minted doctors to become family physicians.

Lynn Dwyer, a general practitioner in St. John's, called the current system "really not efficient."

A patient who comes in with a mild complaint can't simply see a nurse. Dwyer says she also has to see the patient in order to bill MCP — the nurse can't do that themselves. 

"We're paid by the number of patients we see, not by the quality of care that we provide," Dwyer explained.

Quick fixes?

Overhauling the province's payment model isn't an overnight fix. 

But Dwyer said opening an after-hour clinic in populated areas, like one that operated in St. John's until funding ran dry, is a "viable idea" to divert patients from emergency rooms. 

Making bureaucratic changes could ease doctors' workloads, too, she says. Physicians are often faced with mountains of paperwork for insurance companies or workplaces, asked to complete more than 3,000 different types of forms. Dwyer says she loses time writing sick notes when she could be seeing patients.

Dr. Lynn Dwyer was one of the 56 physicians who took part in an after-hours clinic in St. John's. (Paula Gale/CBC)

Slipp, too, says the doctor crunch could be solved in the short-term by undoing a licensing change put in place during COVID-19 lockdowns.

Newfoundland and Labrador depended on foreign-trained doctors for years, especially in rural areas, she says.

"We don't have the same pipeline now that we had always relied on," she said.

Without those changes, Whalen fears he'll keep seeing the number of patients in his ER grow. He likens it to running on a hamster wheel.

But he implores patients to remember that doctors and staff are doing the best they can with the resources they have.

"When we're working, we have the best intentions of every patient at heart," he said.

Read more from CBC Newfoundland and Labrador

With files from Adam Walsh