New Brunswick

Vigilante changes plea, admits to assault, unlawful confinement

What was supposed to be a trial date turned into an admission of guilt Monday on four of the six charges Billy McGillicuddy was facing in connection with what has been framed as an act of vigilantism in the town of McAdam in western New Brunswick.

Billy McGillicuddy to be sentenced Nov. 14

A man stands in a wooded area wearing an orange hat and sunglasses.
Billy McGillicuddy of St. Croix has changed his plea to guilty on four of the six charges he faced after an assault in nearby McAdam. (Billy McGillicuddy/Facebook)

What was supposed to be a trial date Monday turned into an admission of guilt by a New Brunswick man facing a handful of charges stemming from what's been framed as an act of vigilante justice earlier this year.

Billy McGillicuddy of St. Croix was scheduled to stand trial on charges that include assault with a weapon and possession of a weapon stemming from incidents that took place on June 4 in McAdam, about 75 kilometres southwest of Fredericton.

Instead, TJ Burke, McGillicuddy's defence lawyer, informed Fredericton provincial court Judge Cameron Gunn that his client decided to admit to the charges.

Gunn asked McGillicuddy if he understood that by doing so he would forfeit his right to a trial.

McGillicuddy, who has been in custody since his arrest and appeared in court wearing plain clothes, said he did.

The charges include two summary offences of possession of a weapon, a baseball bat, for the purpose of committing an offence, and of assaulting Blake Scott with a baseball bat.

The other two charges were indictable offences of assaulting Scott with a chair and unlawfully confining him.

A statement of facts was not shared in court Monday, as Crown prosecutor Darlene Blundston was feeling unwell.

Instead, it will be shared along with a victim impact statement on Nov. 14, when the sentence is delivered.

Someone wears a shirt with the text "#JUSTICEFORBILLY."
Supporters of McGillicuddy showed up last summer outside the court wearing shirts with '#JUSTICEFORBILLY' printed on the front. (Ed Hunter/CBC)

Speaking to CBC News later, Burke said two other indictable charges, of possession of a sawed-off shotgun for the purpose of committing an offence, and pointing the sawed-off shotgun, had been reserved.

He said he was working to have those two charges eventually withdrawn.

McGillicuddy was denied bail after his arrest in June.

He'd originally elected to be tried in Court of King's Bench on four of the charges but changed his election to a trial by judge alone in provincial court in order for it to be heard sooner.

Vigilante justice

About a dozen family members and supporters of McGillicuddy sat in court for the proceedings on Monday.

His first appearance in June drew a turnout of about 50 people, including McAdam Mayor Ken Stannix, who at the time said people in his village were getting frustrated with a rise in property crime.

Ken Stannix standing outside the Fredericton courthouse.
McAdam Mayor Ken Stannix was among supporters who showed up at McGillicuddy's first court appearance back in June. (Joe McDonald/CBC)

"The criminals are getting away with everything," he said.

"I wanted to support the individuals who allegedly took the law into their own hands."

Those concerns led the RCMP to hold a town hall meeting in the village to let residents air their grievances about crime and how police could improve their response.

Stannix said in August that the meeting resulted in the RCMP starting night patrols in the village.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Aidan Cox

Journalist

Aidan Cox is a journalist for the CBC based in Fredericton. He can be reached at aidan.cox@cbc.ca and followed on Twitter @Aidan4jrn.