Montreal

Girard 'assumes full responsibility' for $7M plan to bring NHL pre-season games to Quebec City

Several critics, including opposition parties, have blasted Coalition Avenir Québec's plan to pay up to $7 million to bring two NHL pre-season hockey games to Quebec City next year.

Quebec finance minister says he hears the criticism but stands by the plan

Man crosses arms.
Finance Minister Eric Girard said next year's pre-season games are part of a long process to increase the chances of Quebec City once again having an NHL team. (Sylvain Roy Roussel/CBC)

In an ideal world, bringing two NHL pre-season games to Quebec City would not cost up to $7 million in public money, said the province's finance minister while standing by the plan that has raised eyebrows and sparked controversy.

Last week, the Quebec government announced plans to bring the Los Angeles Kings to Quebec City for two pre-season games at the Videotron Centre — one against the Boston Bruins and another against the Florida Panthers.

Several critics, including opposition parties, have blasted Coalition Avenir Québec government's move, describing it as careless, given the province's fiscal challenges.

"I heard and took note of the severe criticism, the very negative reaction," Finance Minister Eric Girard said Tuesday, before reporters peppered him with questions.

He said he would have loved for the games to cost $2 million less and tried to negotiate a lower number.

"It was that or nothing," Girard said, adding that the project was his idea.

"I assume full responsibility for it," he added.

WATCH | A breakdown of plan to bring the LA Kings to Quebec City: 

Quebec wants to help pay for an LA Kings training camp in Quebec City

1 year ago
Duration 1:28
Finance Minister Éric Girard announced the province would fund up to $7 million for the LA Kings NHL team to hold its hockey training camp in Quebec City next year. Critics are asking where that money is coming from.

Gestev, a property of Quebecor, is the organizer of the event and the recipient of the subsidy.

La Presse reported that the money comes from a government fund for the Quebec City region that is normally used to subsidize local community groups or small, artisanal shops.

Girard said the province is committed to paying up to $7 million to compensate for financial losses.

On Tuesday, the minister said those losses are expected to be tied to player travel and accommodations as well as money paid to the Bruins and the Panthers who are losing out on ticket and concession sales for games that would normally have been played in their home arenas.  

Québec Solidaire (QS), one of the opposition parties at the National Assembly, is expected to table a motion on Tuesday asking the Quebec government to cancel its plans to subsidize the event.

Girard quickly shot down that possibility, saying it's important for governments to honour the contracts it signs.

He also said next year's games are part of a process of potentially bringing an NHL hockey to Quebec City, echoing the premier's words from last weekend.

He defended the project by saying Quebec City would be hosting a high-quality product.

Four men smiling
A week after announcing plans to spend up to $7 million to bring NHL pre-season hockey to Quebec City, the province's finance minister Eric Girard, centre right, is standing by the move. (Radio-Canada)

He pointed to the Kings, Bruins and Panthers as being among the better teams in the league this season. He also said the fact the pre-season games will be played close to the start of next year's regular season increases the likelihood that all three teams will put their best players on the ice. 

In the case of the Kings, the player rosters would include Quebecers Pierre-Luc Dubois and Philip Danault, Girard pointed out.

The minister also questioned the validity of reports that the Montreal Canadiens would have played at the Videotron Centre for free.

"The Canadiens came to Quebec City in 2018," he said. "If they had wanted to come back after that, all they had to do was show interest."

QS co-spokesperson Gabriel Nadeau-Dubois described Girard's justification for the subsidy as "pathetic."

He said the project is proof that François Legault's government is completely out of touch with the reality of Quebecers.

"How could they have thought that Quebecers were going to accept this?" Nadeau-Dubois asked.

Question of optics

This week, hundreds of thousands of public sector workers are on strike, forcing schools across the province to shut down and a slowdown in health and social services. 

When asked about the timing of the announcement for the $7 million plan for pre-season NHL hockey, Girard appeared to downplay the price tag's relevance to the labour dispute.

"There's $8 billion on the table," he said, referring to the province's offers. "If you tell me that all that's missing to wrap up negotiations is [seven million], we'll give it up right away."

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Antoni Nerestant has been with CBC Montreal since 2015. He's worked as a video journalist, a sports reporter and a web writer, covering everything from Quebec provincial politics to the 2022 Beijing Olympics.