2 men found guilty in trial that exposed 'unthinkable cruelty of human smuggling': U.S. prosecutor
Steve Shand and Harshkumar Patel convicted after family froze to death near Manitoba-Minnesota border in 2022
A Minnesota jury deliberated for less than 90 minutes Friday before convicting two men on human smuggling charges in a case where a family from India froze to death in Manitoba while trying to walk across the Canada-U.S. border.
Steve Shand of Florida and Harshkumar Patel, an Indian national arrested in Chicago, were each found guilty on all four counts they faced related to bringing unauthorized people into the U.S., transporting them and profiting from it.
"This trial exposed the unthinkable cruelty of human smuggling and of those criminal organizations that value profit and greed over humanity," U.S. Attorney Andrew Luger said at the federal courthouse in Fergus Falls, Minn., where the trial was held this week, following Friday's verdict.
"Our office prosecutes crimes every day, but what was revealed in this trial was far beyond even some of the most significant criminal behaviour we have seen and we have addressed," he said.
"To earn a few thousand dollars, these traffickers put men, women and children in extraordinary peril.... A father, mother and two children froze to death in sub-zero temperatures.
"The words 'immoral depravity' are the best that I have to describe the conduct that led to this terrible, terrible result."
One of Patel's lawyers, Thomas Leinenweber, said he was disappointed by the verdicts and hinted at a possible appeal.
"It was a very tragic case, and [Patel] will be looking at his options," he said outside the courthouse shortly after the verdict was announced.
The prosecution had argued Shand and Patel were part of an international smuggling ring that brought people from India to Canada on student visas, then sent them on foot across the border to the U.S.
They were accused of carrying out smuggling trips between Manitoba and Minnesota on several occasions in December 2021 and January 2022.
Patel was alleged to have organized the logistics and paid Shand for picking up migrants on the U.S. side in rented vehicles.
Shand was arrested while driving a van on a remote road just south of the border during a blizzard on Jan. 19, 2022, when the temperature was –23 C, but the wind chill made it feel like the –35 C to –38 C range.
There were two adult migrants in the van and several others were found on foot nearby.
A U.S. border patrol agent testified that when he opened a backpack from the group and found a diaper, his heart sank because he knew there were others missing.
Hours later, the frozen bodies of Jagdish Patel, 39; his wife Vaishaliben Patel, 37; their 11-year-old daughter, Vihangi; and their three-year-old son, Dharmik, were found in a field in Manitoba, metres from the U.S. border. They were dressed in jeans and light jackets, and the boy's body was cradled in his father's arms.
Patel is a common name in India, and the family was not related to Harshkumar Patel.
'They can never tell me why': father
The two men convicted "can never tell me why they took my children in the cold," Jagdish Patel's father, Baldev Patel, told The Canadian Press in a phone interview after Friday's verdict.
"They can never tell me why they did what they did," he said, speaking in Hindi from his home in Dingucha, a village in the Gujarat state of western India. "It's up to God to bring peace and justice."
Baldev Patel said he's still numb from losing his son, daughter-in-law and grandchildren.
He has said his son held different jobs, including teaching, farming and selling kites, but nothing worked out in India. His son reached out when the family got to Canada and was happy about going to the U.S.
Kevin Paul, one of the jurors in the trial for Shand and Harshkumar Patel, said the story of the Patel family struck a chord with him and the rest of his peers on the jury.
"I grew up in North Dakota … and it's pretty brutal," Paul said outside the courthouse Friday morning. "I couldn't imagine [having to] do what they had to do out there, in the middle of nowhere."
He believes justice was served, he said.
Jury saw records of calls, texts
Jurors began deliberating Friday morning, and the verdict was announced shortly after noon CT.
The trial, which began Monday, heard that migrants in India commonly commit to paying up to $100,000 to be smuggled from Canada into the U.S., with many paying off the debt by working low-wage jobs in big cities, such as Chicago.
The jury saw records of dozens of calls and texts between phones allegedly belonging to Shand, Harshkumar Patel and others.
The texts discussed the prices for carrying people, rental vehicles, the dangerous cold and specific locations in a remote section of the border.
Flight and car rental records showed Shand travelling from his home in Florida to the border in Minnesota, then to the Chicago region. Bank records revealed Shand, who owned a small taxi company, and his wife deposited $36,000 US in their accounts during the weeks of the smuggling operations.
One migrant who was on the deadly trek with the family testified he and others were driven to an area in Manitoba and told to walk in a straight line to a waiting van in the U.S. It was cold and dark and, with the blowing snow, he became separated from the group but made it across.
Court heard another migrant picked up by border agents was suffering from severe hypothermia, fading in and out of consciousness. She was flown to Minneapolis for medical care.
Shand's lawyers argued he was simply a taxi driver, who was offered money by Patel to pick people up in different locations and was unaware he was doing anything wrong until the day of his arrest.
Harshkumar Patel's lawyers said their client was misidentified. Patel was only arrested in February of this year, and his lawyers said that, unlike Shand, there is no evidence he was near the border.
His lawyers also said the prosecution was wrong in alleging a contact named "Dirty Harry" in Shand's phone, with whom the messages and phone calls were shared, was Patel. The prosecution provided evidence the number had been used by Patel on a government document.
RCMP have not made any arrests in the case in Canada but have said their investigation is ongoing. Police in India have said three men face related charges there and officials were working to extradite two men from Canada to face charges.
One of those two, Fenil Patel, was mentioned in the Minnesota trial.
Manuel Jimenez, a special agent with Homeland Security, testified that car rental records showed Fenil Patel rented a vehicle in Toronto on Jan. 17, 2022, and drove it to Winnipeg, dropping it off in the Manitoba capital the next day — the same day the family who died was taken to the border.
Another witness, Rajinder Singh, told the trial Fenil Patel was a smuggling organizer on the Canadian side of the border. Singh also said the family had called Patel while they were trying to cross to say it was too cold to continue.
Singh said Patel told the family to turn around and he would have someone pick them up where they started, but it was a lie because there was no one there.
Sentencing dates were tentatively set for March. Some of the offences carry a maximum 10 years in prison.
With files from The Canadian Press's Hina Alam and CBC