Hamilton

Paris, Ont., man challenging Canada Post's decision to cancel delivery to his rural home

David Kirby of Paris Ont. is wondering why, after 30 years, Canada Post has deemed the curb near his mailbox unsafe — cancelling delivery to his rural home.

Canada Post claims a raised curb and increased traffic along Highway 24 is creating safety concerns

David Kirby of Paris Ont. is looking for answers from Canada Post about why the curb near his mailbox is making delivery to his home unsafe. (Laura Clementson/CBC)

David Kirby of Paris, Ont., is wondering why, after 30 years, Canada Post has deemed the curb near his mailbox unsafe — cancelling delivery to his rural home.

The curb separates the asphalt of Brant Road, or Highway 24 — a busy stretch of road from the gravel strip designed as a drain system to prevent pooling.

The mailbox is located on the grass lawn in front of the gravel gully.

"It's been here an awful long time and it just seems mighty odd that suddenly we can't be delivered to," said Kirby.

Kirby was sent a letter on Nov. 12 from Canada Post letting him know his mailbox was under a traffic safety review and it didn't meet established safety criteria, making it "potentially dangerous" for delivery personnel and the "motoring public," read the letter. 

He was given 15 days to move his mailbox about 45 metres away, past the solid curb where Canada Post placed a flag marker to map out their preferred location.

A close up of the raised curb Canada Post has deemed "unsafe" after the crown corporation conducted a safety review of this property along with a few other addresses along Brant Road. (Laura Clementson/CBC)

"It's pretty crazy really because this rain gully's been here for 30 years and they've crossed it about 10,000 times to deliver and it's never been a problem," said Kirby.

Kirby is holding his ground and hasn't moved the box.

He got another letter from Canada Post dated Dec. 11 that said it hadn't received a response from Kirby, offering some options to receive his mail in the meantime — understanding that residents may not be able to relocate their mailboxes until the ground has thawed.

"It's been winter and the ground's solid and suddenly you're asked to move your mailbox to a location which may not necessarily be any safer," said Kirby. 

David Kirby and his family have been in the home along Brant Road that borders Brantford for the past four years. Kirby says his house has been around since 1858 and rural delivery to the property started in 1908. (Laura Clementson/CBC)

He says although 45 metres isn't too far away, snow banks could create issues and he'd constantly have to make sure there was a path accessible for Canada Post.

He and his family have been in the house that borders Brantford for the past four years — and after doing some research he says there haven't been changes made to the road or to postal delivery in the past 30 years.

He also says his house has been around since 1858 and rural delivery to the property started in 1908.

Kirby isn't alone. He says six other neighbours are facing the same issue — some of whom are older and have been asked to move their mailboxes further than his relocation.

Safety concerns

He's now taking on the crown corporation, demanding an explanation as to why the road isn't safe anymore, but says he hasn't been given the explanation he's looking for.

"Unfortunately they don't really include you in the process. It's very bureaucratic," said Kirby.

In a statement to CBC News, Canada Post said as an employer it has the responsibility to ensure the workplace is safe for employees.

"When an issue is raised regarding safety, Canada Post representatives and our health and safety committee will conduct a review to evaluate what is causing the potential dangers, and how these conditions can be improved," read the statement.

Canada Post is asking residents like David Kirby to move his rural mailbox to a location where postal workers don't have to drive over the raised curb. (Laura Clementson/CBC)

Canada Post says the safety concerns relate to the raised curb along with the increased traffic volume.

"When traffic safety issues were raised on Highway 24 in Brantford, Canada Post representatives and our health and safety committee determined that the increased volume of traffic on the highway, as well as the raised curb blocking the mailboxes of some addresses, including the one you have noted, delivery to the mailboxes at these addresses was deemed unsafe." 

The speed limit along the road is 80 km/h.

"It's strictly because they're saying that driving the van over this rain gully is so dangerous. It's ludicrous because it's only dangerous if you want to cross it at doing 80 km/h and you should never be entering the hard shoulder at 80 km/h," said Kirby. "You should be slowing down to a nice safe speed."

Getting attention

Kirby says he's reached out to local representatives including Phil McColeman, MP for Brantford-Brant, who has written a letter to Canada's Minster of Public Services and Procurement, Carla Qualtrough.

"I'm writing to respectfully request that you ask senior officials at Canada Post to revisit this issue, and conduct further study and consultation with residents, to ensure the safety and accessibility of all involved is considered," read McColeman's Dec. 20 letter.

A flag marks a suggested location mapped out by Canada Post for David Kirby to move his mailbox, away from the raised curb. It's about 45 metres away from where his current mailbox is located. (Laura Clementson/CBC)

In the statement to CBC News Canada Post said it provided residents with temporary mail delivery options until the issue is resolved, or customers can choose to permanently receive their mail at a community mailbox instead of relocating their rural mailboxes.

"If Canada Post wants to have a mandate of getting rid of rural delivery then that should be their mandate and it apply to everyone," said Kirby.

laura.clementson@cbc.ca

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Laura Clementson is a producer for CBC's The National. She can be reached at laura.clementson@cbc.ca. Follow Laura on Twitter @LauraClementson.