Niagara West-Glanbrook byelection: Will it be about hydro rates or Sam Oosterhoff?
The lead candidate is a 19-year-old social conservative who has ideas that appear to conflict with PC leader Patrick Brown's. He's been elusive with the media. If he wins, he'll be Ontario's youngest MPP ever.
I think voters deserve to know the truth.- Deb Matthews, Deputy Premier
But candidates in the Niagara West-Glanbrook byelection say the main issue at the polls Thursday will likely be something different — hydro rates.
PC candidate Sam Oosterhoff, Liberal Vicky Ringuette and NDP candidate Mike Thomas are vying for Tim Hudak's old seat on Thursday. The riding, along with Ottawa-Vanier, will elect a new MPP on Thursday.
Thomas is a retired police officer and former head of Hamilton's police union. Ringuette is a Hamilton lawyer. Oosterhoff is a Brock University student who won the nomination over a former MP and a regional councillor. He's generated controversy over his views on same-sex marriage, abortion and the Ontario government's sex education curriculum.
While the Liberals have tried to draw attention to Oosterhoff's social views, all three candidates say people's feelings about their electricity bills will likely influence votes.
- 19-year-old Sam Oosterhoff wins PC nomination for Niagara West-Glanbrook
- The teen candidate that spells trouble for PC leader Patrick Brown: Fisher
NDP leader Andrea Horwath has campaigned with Thomas numerous times. The most recent appearance — on Wednesday — focused on hydro rates and the party's opposition to the sale of Hydro One.
The pair met with Smithville resident Richelle McDonald to talk about her skyrocketing bills.
"I have heard stories like Richelle's regularly from people every day while I'm knocking on doors," Thomas said in a media release. "Hydro rates are too high, they have been for a long time and Kathleen Wynne isn't doing much about it."
Brown was in the riding Monday to talk about electricity rates too. He and Oosterhoff visited the Grimsby Diner.
"Skyrocketing rates are the No. 1 issue I am hearing at the doors," Oosterhoff said in a media release.
"If the Wynne Liberals were serious about addressing the crisis they created, they would stop signing contracts for power we don't need, stop selling hydro to our competitors for a loss, and stop the fire sale of Hydro One."
Ringuette has heard about electricity rates at the doors too. She tells people the Liberals will reduce the rates by 8 per cent in January by removing the HST portion of their bills. She also talks about a new deal to import electricity from Quebec. The Liberals have made positive changes to hydro in Ontario, she says.
- What Sam Oosterhoff's nomination means for Patrick Brown's PCs
- Former Hamilton police union head running for Tim Hudak's old seat
"When it does come up, we're able to have some good discussions in terms of why it's important to have done the upgrades we did," she told CBC Hamilton last week.
When it does come up, we're able to have some good discussions in terms of why it's important to have done the upgrades we did.- Vicky Ringuette
"Once constituents have more information about this at their disposal, it's been quite positive."
Other commonly mentioned issues include home care for seniors, and a planned expansion to West Lincoln Memorial Hospital in Grimsby, which the Liberals scrapped in 2012.
But largely, Ringuette's campaign has taken pains to differentiate her from Oosterhoff. The Liberals said Wednesday that Brown has masked the young candidate's "true views" as part of his ongoing effort to make the party appear centrist.
"The contrast couldn't be clearer," said Deputy Premier Deb Matthews while campaigning with Ringuette last week.
"For me, the big issue is about being honest with the public about who you are and what your values are." With Brown, "his position changes according to whose vote he's trying to get."
Brown's assertions that he supports same-sex marriage are "diametrically opposed to Sam's position," Matthews said. "I think voters deserve to know the truth."
Sam's got his beliefs, his views ... I'm running on my experience.- Mike Thomas
Thomas, meanwhile, has mostly stayed away from criticizing Oosterhoff. He and Horwath skirted the subject in an interview with CBC Hamilton last week, emphasizing Thomas's qualities instead.
"Sam's got his beliefs, his views," Thomas said. "They're intrinsic in him. I'm running on my experience … We've got good solutions. We're working hard. Those are the things we're arguing for."
Oosterhoff couldn't be reached for comment this week. His website refers to his support of parents being primary educators, a point he makes when asked about the Liberals's sex education curriculum. His Facebook likes include the "We can end abortion" community and the Libertarian Christian Institute — as well as the indie bands Imagine Dragons and Death Cab for Cutie.
Whatever the result, Matthews said it won't necessarily be foreshadowing the 2018 provincial election.
"Byelections are funny things and I always hesitate to read too much into them," she said. "We can say Vicky Ringuette is a really strong candidate."