Calgary

Accused serial rapist Richard Mantha fires lawyers mid-trial

Accused serial rapist Richard Mantha fired his lawyers on Tuesday, seven days into his sexual assault trial.

The 59-year-old is on trial in Calgary on 20 charges involving 7 women

A man wearing a leather jacket sits on a motorcycyle.
Richard Mantha, 59, is accused of drugging and raping seven women. Mantha's trial got underway in Calgary on Jan. 19. (Richard Mantha/Facebook)

Accused serial rapist Richard Mantha fired his lawyers on Tuesday, seven days into his sexual assault trial in Calgary. 

The trial was adjourned and Mantha will return to court on March 1 to provide the judge with an update on whether he's hired a new lawyer. It is not clear if the trial will continue or if it will be rebooked to start from the beginning. 

Mantha, 59, faces 20 charges involving seven women. His trial got underway on Jan. 19 and was set to run until Feb. 9.

On Tuesday afternoon, following a lunch break, defence lawyer Kim Arial told the judge that Mantha was "discharging" her services as well as those of co-counsel André Ouellette.

'Disappointing,' says judge 

Justice Judith Shriar called the situation a "disappointing development."

Mantha's move comes after powerful testimony from four women, who testified he drugged and sexually assaulted them. A fifth woman was scheduled to testify Wednesday. 

Arial and Ouellette vigorously cross-examined each complainant. 

"I don't think it's fair to me to sit here and put my life and my future in the hands of people who don't seem to care," said Mantha.

'Vulnerable witnesses'

Prosecutor Dominique Mathurin argued the trial should proceed with Mantha representing himself

"I have witnesses, vulnerable witnesses ready to tell their story," she said in French. 

But Mantha argued he should be given time to find new representation. 

"I've read some of the Charter of Rights and I would like 30 days minimum to be able to obtain legal assistance," Mantha said.

The judge agreed to Mantha's application for an adjournment. 

Mantha's charges include sexual assault with a gun, sexual assault with a knife, kidnapping, forcible confinement and administering noxious substances.

The charges are connected to allegations he drugged and raped vulnerable women, most of whom, at the time, struggled with addiction and/or were involved in Calgary's sex trade. 

Mantha requested to be tried in French. Everything besides witness testimony is taking place in French.

All of the witnesses testified in English and he did not once use the services of his court-provided French translator. 

In explaining his decision to fire his lawyers, Mantha went back and forth between English and French. 

Before court adjourned for the day, Mantha indicated he is reconsidering whether he will continue in French depending on the lawyer he finds.

Clarifications

  • An earlier version of this story reflected information provided by police that all of Mantha's alleged victims were involved in Calgary's sex trade at the time they were targeted. In fact, one of the complainants testified that she was neither in the sex trade or struggling with addiction at the time of her alleged assault. CBC News has changed the wording in our stories published since her testimony to align with that fact.
    Mar 27, 2024 10:06 AM MT

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Meghan Grant

CBC Calgary crime reporter

Meghan Grant is a justice affairs reporter. She has been covering courts, crime and stories of police accountability in southern Alberta for more than a decade. Send Meghan a story tip at meghan.grant@cbc.ca.

With files from Laurence Taschereau