Calgary

Pit bull that killed 86-year-old Calgary woman to be euthanized, owner pleads guilty

The owner of three pit bulls involved in a fatal attack on a 86-year-old woman pleaded guilty Wednesday and agreed to have one of the dogs euthanized.

Denis Bagaric pleaded guilty to City of Calgary bylaw offences

Older woman with short blonde hair and a wool sweater.
Betty Ann Williams, 86, was gardening in her back alley in Capitol Hill when she was attacked by at least one pit bull in June 2022. She died from her injuries. (mhfh.com)

The owner of three pit bulls involved in a fatal attack on a 86-year-old woman pleaded guilty Wednesday and agreed to have one of the dogs euthanized. 

Denis Bagaric pleaded guilty to having animals running at large and animals attacking a person causing severe injury, both offences under City of Calgary bylaws.

Although an agreed statement of facts was filed as part of the plea, Bagaric only admitted that one of the three dogs was involved in the fatal attack on Betty Ann Williams, 86.

On June 5, 2022, his American Staffordshire dogs Bossii, Cinnamon and Smoki escaped his fenced backyard in the northwest community of Capitol Hill, according to the agreed statement of facts.

A man lies on a sofa with three pit bull dogs.
Denis Bagaric pleaded guilty to City of Calgary bylaw offences after three of his pit bulls escaped his fenced backyard. At least one of the dogs killed Bagaric's 86-year-old neighbour. (Denis Bagaric/Facebook)

The dogs got into the alley where Williams was gardening.

According to Bagaric, only Smoki was involved in the attack on Williams, who died from her injuries. 

On Wednesday, Bagaric agreed to having Smoki euthanized. The city has applied to have the other two dogs put down as well. 

But there is no agreement between the prosecution and defence as to the involvement of Cinnamon and Bossii in the fatal attack.

A Gardiner hearing — when evidence is called during sentencing to determine some of the facts — took place following the plea Wednesday. 

Justice Gord Wong, who hasn't yet made findings related to Cinnamon and Bossi's involvement, heard testimony from a neighbour who saw all three dogs in the alley and near Williams. 

Originally, both Bagaric and his partner, Talyn Calkins, each faced a dozen bylaw charges.

But as part of the plea, all charges were withdrawn against Calkins, with Bagaric pleading guilty to two of the 12 offences. 

Prosecutor Ben Leung and defence lawyer Rabi Ahmed agreed Bagaric should pay a fine of $15,000. 

But Leung also asked the judge to impose a 15-year pet ownership prohibition, while Ahmed argued his client should be allowed to have dogs again. 

The sentencing hearing was adjourned so written submissions can be filed on that point.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Meghan Grant

CBC Calgary crime reporter

Meghan Grant is a justice affairs reporter. She has been covering courts, crime and stories of police accountability in southern Alberta for more than a decade. Send Meghan a story tip at meghan.grant@cbc.ca.