British Columbia

Nelson mulls crackdown on panhandling, proposes fines

Nelson City Council wants to crack down on panhandling directly outside of public washrooms, telephones, ATMs, bus stops, cafes, and other public spaces.

Bylaw officers say 50% of panhandlers "are confrontational, use extreme profanity..."

The City of Nelson wants to impose stricter rules on panhandlers and is considering charging fines up to $500. (Getty Images)

Nelson city council plans to crackdown on panhandling directly outside of public washrooms, telephones, ATMs, bus stops, cafes and other frequently visited areas. 

The city says it is responding to an increase in "aggressive panhandling," which "creates a safety issue for all involved." 

"Aggressive panhandling is when somebody is being pursued by an individual for money and feels intimidated...or they don't feel comfortable in the downtown streets. They don't feel safe," said Mayor Deb Kozak. 

Requested by bylaw officers

According to the staff report, bylaw officers believe half of the city's panhandlers "are confrontational, use extreme profanity and seem to need extra incentive [police involvement] or encouragement to comply."

This bylaw would among other things make it illegal for panhandlers to block pathways, touch another person while panhandling and panhandle after sunset. 

If passed, violators could face fines up to $500.

"It certainly doesn't seem to make sense that we would be fining people money or a substantial sum of money for someone who really doesn't have any," admitted Kozak.

"That's one of the elements that will be taken back by staff and reworked."

Final decision to come

Council first considered the change in mid-September, but, following an influx of mixed public feedback, delayed its final decision and returned the proposal to staff for revisions.

"There were people who are really concerned that there are people in our community who really need money.

"Panhandling is a part of their daily existence. They need that extra cash to survive," she said.

Still, Kozak said police and bylaw enforcement officers need greater clarity on this issue, and she hopes staff come back with clear recommendations for improved regulations. 

"I want something that makes sense and that doesn't penalize people who are just trying to get by either," she said.

"For me, it's about having safe, welcoming, vibrant streets. We want to maintain that. We certainly don't want people to feel intimidated by being in our downtown." 


To hear the full interview with Nelson Mayor Deb Kozak, listen to the audio labelled: Nelson City Council mulls a crackdown on panhandling