British Columbia

Gitxsan artist demands apology for use of her design on lacrosse league shirt

The National Lacrosse League is selling orange Every Child Matters T-shirts with a logo it says is the creation of staff with the Halifax Thunderbirds team.

Michelle Stoney of Hazelton, B.C., says she created the stylized hand for Orange Shirt Day 2 years ago

Gitxsan artist Michelle Stoney has accused the National Lacrosse League of stealing her creative work, right, and putting a version, left, on orange T-shirts they are selling to increase awareness about the damage caused by residential schools and raise money for charity. (Michelle Stoney/Facebook)

A Gitxsan artist has accused a U.S.-based men's professional indoor lacrosse league and two Canadian lacrosse teams of stealing her T-shirt design that honours survivors of the Indian residential school system.

Michelle Stoney of Hazelton in northwestern B.C. says the U.S.-based National Lacrosse League and its two Canadian members — Halifax Thunderbirds and Vancouver Warriors — are  selling orange T-shirts with a similar hand logo for fundraising purposes.

She says she first saw a Warriors' Facebook post last week which featured a photo of a player wearing the shirt, with the design credited to another person.

"I can't really explain the feeling, but it was … it was horrible," she told host Carolina de Ryk on CBC's Daybreak North.

In Stoney's original design created for Orange Shirt Day on Sept. 30, 2020, mountains and trees represent the Gitxsan Nation, the flowers represent children, and the feathers represent children who were lost in residential schools. Sept. 30 is now a national holiday and is officially called National Day for Truth and Reconciliation.

Stoney is one of the many Indigenous artists across Canada whose works have been used by online vendors and companies alike without permission.

Original creative work 'flipped'

Stoney says it looks like the Thunderbirds designer "flipped" her work by tracing the hand and adding the words Every Child Matters to replace the mountain, tree and flowers on the palm of her piece. 

A Google search shows many shirts bearing logos similar to Stoney's are being sold on various e-commerce platforms.

In the design created by Michelle Stoney, mountains and trees represent the Gitxsan Nation, the flowers represent children, and the feathers represent children who were lost in residential schools. (Michelle Stoney, Gitxsan artist/Facebook)

Stoney says she is fine with lending her creative works, such as the Indigenous feather colouring pages, for other people to use, as long as they ask for her consent to collaborate.

Lacrosse league, team promise investigation 

Stoney says she contacted the Warriors who apologized and removed their Facebook post last Thursday.

"At the time we were using information provided to us regarding the artist credited for the design. We understand that this information may be incorrect and have taken the post down to slow the spread of misinformation," the lacrosse team wrote.

The league told CBC News in an emailed statement it is investigating the T-shirt design. 

A now-removed promotional photos shows a member of the Vancouver Warriors wearing the Every Child Matters T-shirt that artist Michelle Stoney says is an uncredited copy of her work. (Vancouver Warriors)

CBC has reached out to the Thunderbirds for comments and didn't hear back by deadline, but Stoney says the team told her it will investigate the T-shirt design and promised to speak to her this week.

She says while she doesn't want to sue anybody, she wants a public apology from the team: "I want to find out whose exact idea was it to take my design, because right now people are just blaming other people about it and nobody's taking blame for it."

"You can't steal existing work."

Michelle Stoney says she wants a public apology for the appropriation of her design. (Nolan Guichon)

Support is available for anyone affected by their experience at residential schools or by the latest reports.

A national Indian Residential School Crisis Line has been set up to provide support for former students and those affected. People can access emotional and crisis referral services by calling the 24-hour national crisis line: 1-866-925-4419.


Subscribe to Daybreak North on CBC Listen or your favourite podcast app, and connect with CBC Northern British Columbia on FacebookTwitter and Instagram

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Winston Szeto

Digital journalist

Winston Szeto is a journalist with CBC News based in Kelowna, B.C. in the unceded territories of the Syilx. He writes stories about new immigrants and LGBTQ communities. He has contributed to CBC investigative journalism programs Marketplace and The Fifth Estate. Winston speaks Cantonese and Mandarin fluently and has a working knowledge of German and Japanese. He came to Canada in 2018 from Hong Kong, and is proud to be Canadian. Send him tips at winston.szeto@cbc.ca.

With files from Jason Peters, Kate Partridge and Daybreak North