British Columbia

B.C. SPCA seizes animals from woman it lost 2014 defamation case to

The B.C. SPCA has seized at least 39 animals from a woman with whom it has a complicated past.

SPCA first took animals from the woman's rescue shelter in 2012

The B.C. SPCA raid a property in Langley on September 19, 2016. (Jared Thomas/CBC)

The B.C. SPCA has seized at least 39 animals from a woman with whom it has a complicated past.

Around 11 a.m. PT, Monday, 10 people from the organization arrived at a property in Langley, after receiving a complaint that animals were in distress.

Carrying crates with animals inside one at a time, they took 18 cats and 21 farm animals — and were also examining more than 40 dogs to determine whether they needed to be taken into care. 

"Our constables and a community veterinarian are on the property and, based on the their assessment, we are currently removing animals who meet the definition of distress under the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act and who require immediate care," said Marcie Moriarty, chief prevention and enforcement officer for the B.C. SPCA, in a statement. 

The SPCA also said it was not a puppy mill investigation, and that no charges had been laid. They said the animals seized were "suffering from malnutrition and other medical issues," but declined to comment otherwise. 

'It breaks my heart' 

Sandra Simans successfully sued the B.C. SPCA for defamation after her animals were seized in 2012. (Jared Thomas/CBC)

It's the second time Sandra Simans has had her animals seized by the B.C. SPCA. 

"I want people to know the truth about what's going on and not jump to a conclusion that we're some kind of bad, crazy folks that are abusing animals," she said.

Simans operates a rescue shelter for older animals. In 2012, the SPCA seized 52 dogs and 19 cats from her facility, which was then in Burnaby.

The organization subsequently lost a defamation case against Simans, after a judge ruled the SPCA's news release suggested she had injured an emaciated Chihuahua.

Simans argued in that case, the SPCA was overzealous in taking her animals — and says the same situation is playing out this time again.

"Were they in perfect condition? No. I don't think you're going to find a rescue [animal] that is. Every rescue is battling. It doesn't make you an abuser," she said, adding that they were not adding any new animals to the facility. 

"I would have liked if they said, 'this isn't perfect, so what are you going to do about this?' Why does this have to be that somebody becomes a bad guy at the end of it?"

"It breaks my heart to not be allowed in my home."