World

Israel's defence minister orders army to prepare for Gaza residents' departure

Israel's defence minister has ordered the army to prepare a plan to allow the "voluntary departure" of residents from Gaza, Israeli media said, after President Trump drew widespread condemnation over U.S. plans to take over the strip.

Israel Katz cites Canada as one of many countries that could take Palestinians

A woman and two children are shown huddling near an umbrella while walking on a muddy road. Other people and low-rise buildings are in the background.
Palestinians endured a rainy and windy day on Thursday, as U.S. President Donald Trump's vision for the future of Gaza continued to reverberate within the territory and around the world. (Dawoud Abu Alkas/Reuters)

Israel's defence minister ordered the army on Thursday to prepare a plan to allow the "voluntary departure" of residents from Gaza, after U.S. President Donald Trump drew widespread condemnation for announcing plans to take over the strip.

Defence Minister Israel Katz hailed Trump's announcement that the United States would aim to take control of Gaza, resettle the more than two million Palestinians living there and transform the territory into the "Riviera of the Middle East."

"I welcome President Trump's bold plan, Gaza residents should be allowed the freedom to leave and emigrate, as is the norm around the world," Katz said on X.

Katz said his plan would include exit options via land crossings, as well as special arrangements for departure by sea and air.

Displacement of Palestinians is one of the most sensitive and explosive issues in the Middle East. Forced or coerced displacement of a population under military occupation is a war crime, banned under the 1949 Geneva Conventions.

A man, wearing a blue blazer and red tie and yellow ribbon on his lapel, sits in a meeting room at a desk behind a microphone.
Israeli Defence Minister Israel Katz, pictured in January 2024, ordered the army on Thursday to prepare a plan to allow the 'voluntary departure' of residents from the Gaza strip. (John Thys/The Associated Press)

Israeli strikes which killed tens of thousands of people over the past 16 months have forced Palestinians to repeatedly move around within Gaza, seeking safety.

But many say they will never leave the enclave because they fear permanent displacement, like the "Nakba," or catastrophe, when hundreds of thousands were dispossessed from homes in the war at the birth of the state of Israel in 1948.

Many were driven out or fled to Gaza, the West Bank and neighbouring Arab states including to Jordan, Syria and Lebanon, where their descendants still live in refugee camps. Israel disputes the account that they were forced out.

Katz said countries who have opposed Israel's military operations in Gaza should take in the Palestinians.

"Countries like Spain, Ireland, Norway, and others, which have levelled accusations and false claims against Israel over its actions in Gaza, are legally obligated to allow any Gaza resident to enter their territories," he said.

x
Palestinians warm themselves by a fire amid the rubble of destroyed buildings in Jabalia. (Omar Al-Qattaa/AFP/Getty Images)

"Their hypocrisy will be exposed if they refuse to do so. There are countries like Canada, which has a structured immigration program, that have previously expressed a willingness to accept Gaza residents."

Ireland was also mentioned as a possible destination for Palestinians by Katz, but that country's Foreign Ministry quickly rejected the suggestion in a statement.

"The objective must be a massive scale up of aid into Gaza, return of basic services and a clear framework under which those displaced can return," the ministry said in an emailed statement. "Any comments to the contrary are unhelpful and a source of distraction."

WATCH | Trump's Gaza plan draws swift rebukes:

White House defends Trump's Gaza plan that critics call unlawful nonsense

20 hours ago
Duration 6:02
Top aides to U.S. President Donald Trump are defending his Gaza takeover plan as critics — including world leaders, UN officials and Palestinians themselves — are condemning the idea.

The U.S. president early Thursday expounded on the ideas he publicly pronounced two days earlier at the White House in a joint news conference with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. 

Trump said on social media that "the Gaza Strip would be turned over to the United States by Israel at the conclusion of fighting," and that "no soldiers by the U.S. would be needed" without elaborating.

Trump's controversial idea, which has sparked anger around the Middle East, comes as Israel and militant group Hamas are expected to begin talks on the second round of a fragile ceasefire plan to end almost 16 months of fighting in Gaza.

Katz's plan will include exit options via land crossings, as well as special arrangements for departure by sea and air, the Israeli broadcaster Channel 12 reported.

Trump's plan condemned

Trump drew rebukes on Wednesday over his plan within Gaza, and from world powers Russia, China and Germany.

Abdel Ghani, a father of four living with his family in the ruins of their Gaza City home, told Reuters in a text message that they were staying put.

"Is he nuts?" he said of Trump. "We will not sell our land for you, real estate developer. We are hungry, homeless, and desperate but we are not collaborators. If he wants to help, let him come and rebuild for us here."

Regional heavyweight Saudi Arabia rejected the proposal outright and Jordan's King Abdullah, who will meet Trump at the White House next week, said on Wednesday he rejected any attempts to annex land and displace Palestinians.

 A man rides in a donkey-pulled cart past the rubble of destroyed buildings.
A man rides a donkey-pulled cart past the rubble of destroyed buildings at Saftawi street in Jabalia, in northern Gaza. Israeli Defence Minister Israel Katz said countries who opposed Israel's military operations in Gaza should take in Palestinians. (Omar Al-Qattaa/AFP/Getty Images)

In a post on X, Iran's Foreign Ministry said Trump's plan is part of Israel's attempt to "completely wipe out the Palestinian people."

An older man sits on a chair in a destroyed house. Outside there are white tents.
A Palestinian man sits amidst the debris of his home in Jabalia in the northern Gaza Strip on Wednesday. Israeli strikes which killed tens of thousands of people over the past 16 months have forced Palestinians to repeatedly move around within Gaza, seeking safety. (Omar Al-Qattaa/AFP)

Trump's plan 'remarkable,' says Netanyahu 

But Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said on Wednesday that Trump's proposal was "remarkable" and urged that it be explored, even as he was not specific about what he believed Trump was offering.

Netanyahu said he did not believe Trump suggested sending U.S. troops to fight Hamas in Gaza, or that Washington would finance rebuilding efforts.

Hamas, which ruled the Gaza Strip before the war, said Trump's proposal was "ridiculous and absurd."

WATCH | The history and obstacles of the two-state solution:

Why a two-state solution is nearly impossible to achieve

12 months ago
Duration 17:47
For decades, world leaders have sold an Israeli-Palestinian two-state solution as the best hope for peace in the region, but is it even possible? CBC’s Ellen Mauro breaks down the major challenges standing in the way.

Since Jan. 25, Trump has repeatedly suggested that Palestinians in Gaza should be taken in by regional Arab nations such as Egypt and Jordan, an idea rejected by both the Arab states and Palestinian leaders. He has given no specifics of his proposal to take over Gaza.

Trump's aides defended his proposal but backed away from elements of it after international condemnation.

Rights groups have condemned as ethnic cleansing Trump's suggestion that Palestinians in the enclave should be permanently displaced, while also proposing a U.S. takeover of Gaza.

Israel's military assault on Gaza, now paused by a fragile ceasefire, has killed more than 47,000 Palestinians in the last 16 months, the Gaza Health Ministry says, and provoked accusations of genocide and war crimes that Israel denies.

The assault repeatedly internally displaced nearly all of Gaza's population and caused a hunger crisis. The war was triggered by a Hamas-led assault on Israel, which killed 1,200 people and saw some 250 taken hostage.