Eller's bizarre goal holds up as winner as Avalanche hand Senators 4th straight loss

Despite their best efforts, the Ottawa Senators came up short against the visiting Colorado Avalanche on Thursday.

Mikko Rantanen had a goal and two assists and Lars Eller scored a bizarre winner as the Avalanche won their fourth straight game with a 5-4 victory over the Sens.

Colorado defenceman Cale Makar had a goal and an assist while Valeri Nichushkin and Evan Rodrigues chipped in with a goal apiece. Nathan MacKinnon notched three assists for the Avalanche (39-22-6) and goaltender Jonas Johansson stopped 31 shots.

Drake Batherson, Shane Pinto, Travis Hamonic and Brady Tkachuk scored for the Senators (33-31-4), who dropped their fourth straight. Tim Stützle had three assists and Mads Sogaard made 25 saves in the Sens net.

WATCH | Eller scores weird winner against Senators:

Controversial goal gives Avalanche win over Senators

2 years ago

Duration 1:08

Lars Eller's strange second period goal proved to be the winner as Colorado defeated Ottawa 5-4.

The Senators, who were coming of a long western road trip, came out sluggish. The Avalanche registered the game's first seven shots and led 2-0 before Ottawa recorded its first shot almost eight minutes into the game.

Makar opened the scoring at 2:35 with a wrist shot from the top of the faceoff dot, and then Nichushkin made it 2-0 on a power play at the five-minute mark.

"The first goal is the biggest goal, for me," Avalanche coach Jared Bednar said.

Ottawa did have 12 of the final 15 shots of the period and were rewarded with a power-play goal as Batherson redirected a slap pass from Stützle with 27 seconds remaining in the opening frame.

"We left it all out there. It's frustrating because you want to get rewarded for all the hard work," Tkachuk said. "I though it was huge character displayed by this group with all the adversity we faced being down three going into the third, just to give us a chance, it's disappointing."

'Result we didn't deserve'

The Avalanche scored three times in the second period, including a very strange goal, to take a 5-2 lead.

After Rantanen gave the Avalanche a 3-1 lead at 4:23, Pinto drew the Senators back to within a goal at 3-2 eight minutes into the period. Rodrigues gave the Avalanche a 4-2 lead at 15:17, and then the weirdness happened.

On what the Senators appeared to think was an icing against the Avalanche, the puck bounced off the end boards and was in the corner of the crease by Sogaard's pad. With Senators' defenceman Jake Sanderson standing next to his netminder, no whistle came to end the play. After a couple of seconds, Eller skated in and jammed the puck past a confused group of Senators at 18:09.

After a lengthy review on a goaltender interference challenge from Senators coach, the goal stood.

Hamonic scored at 2:52 of the third period and then Tkachuk scored on the power play at 13:18 to pull the Senators to within a goal at 5-4, but they got no closer — thanks to a game-saving acrobatic stop by Johansson with five seconds to play.

"They started to bring it to us a little bit in the third, but I thought we defended well," Rodrigues said. "Big faceoffs at the end, and a huge save from Johansson at the end. We got the two points. That's what we wanted."

The Senators will host the Toronto Maple Leafs Saturday and play the Penguins in Pittsburgh Monday.