COVID-19 vaccinations add new twist to MLB trade deadline, add constraints to Blue Jays

This is always a stressful time of year for Major League Baseball's 30 general managers, who are evaluating talent, juggling financial implications and trying to figure out ways to make their teams better as Tuesday's trade deadline approaches.

Now there's another factor in the wheeling-and-dealing calculus — COVID-19 vaccination status.

"It's certainly one of the things that's new that you didn't have to think about," Pirates GM Ben Cherington said. "I think every team obviously wants to feel that the full complement of their roster is available to play, but we're in a new world and there's personal choices."

Arizona Diamondbacks GM Mike Hazen said the vaccine status of players was affecting trade talks "to some degree" but didn't believe it would be a deciding factor in many deals, particularly for teams that don't have to travel to Canada in the near future.

Hazen added that vaccine status is part of a player's medical file, so there shouldn't be any secrets, since teams are free to discuss those details.

As the only MLB team located in Canada, the Toronto Blue Jays have by far the toughest constraints. Foreign nationals who aren't vaccinated against COVID-19 are not allowed to enter Canada, save for limited exceptions that require a 14-day quarantine.

Unvaccinated players are placed on the restricted list, where they are not paid and do not accrue major league service time.

Toronto upgrades will likely have to be vaccinated

That means any upgrades for the Blue Jays — who are right in the middle of the American League playoff race — will almost certainly have to be vaccinated. It also means teams traveling to Toronto for the rest of the regular season have to consider if they're willing to add a player who might miss a crucial series.

The Yankees, Guardians, Rays, Orioles, Red Sox, Angels and Cubs all play games in Toronto after the Aug. 2 deadline. Toronto GM Ross Atkins declined an interview request through a team spokesman.

Several of those players — including hitters Andrew Benintendi and Whit Merrifield — have reportedly been the subjects of trade talks. Benintendi was traded to the Yankees last week. Merrifield, a two-time All-Star, says he may be willing to get the vaccine if it means playing postseason games in Toronto.

Unless all those unvaccinated players change their minds, it sure seems like a home-field advantage for the Blue Jays. They are 34-21 in Toronto and just 23-24 on the road this season.

Missing regular season games is problematic, but the playoffs are even more important.

Post-season games in Canada could play a factor

The Blue Jays are on track to make the postseason, so theoretically, the road to a World Series title could go through Canada. For a team like the Yankees, it would put them at a sizable disadvantage.

Benintendi has said he'd consider getting vaccinated.

"I'm open minded about it," Benintendi said after the trade. "I'm not against it, but time will tell as we get closer, but for now I'm just focused on getting here, getting comfortable, getting to know the guys and winning baseball games."

Of course, there's also a chance the Blue Jays fall out of the playoff race and none of the immediate doomsday scenarios come into play. Many have taken the position of Yankees manager Aaron Boone, who said he hadn't discussed vaccines with Benintendi in the immediate aftermath of the July 27 trade.

"We'll cross that bridge if and when we have to," Boone said.