Manitoba

'Nobody ever thought we would go back': Displaced Birchwood Terrace tenants can return home

Hundreds of residents forced out of Birchwood Terrace after serious structural deterioration left the apartment complex in unsafe living condition have been given the green light to return home. 

City issues a full occupancy permit months after structural deterioration forced evacuation of complex

A woman on a Jets sweater is sitting on couch.
Debby Ross is one of roughly 250 tenants who were forced out of their homes in Birchwood Terrace on May 9 after a serious structural deterioration was found in steel columns of the St. James building's parkade. (Felisha Adam/CBC)

Hundreds of residents forced out of Birchwood Terrace after serious structural deterioration left the apartment complex in unsafe living condition have been given the green light to return home. 

In an email sent to tenants, Ladco Company, which owns the apartment block's property manager, Lakewood Agencies, said the City of Winnipeg granted Birchwood Terrace an occupancy permit on Tuesday — although no moving date has been fixed yet. 

The apartment complex in the St. James neighbourhood was evacuated on May 9 after deterioration was detected in the steel columns of its parkade, putting the entire building's stability into question. 

Roughly 250 tenants were forced out of their homes on short notice, leaving people scrambling and some living in hotels for more than seven months.

But on Wednesday, the City of Winnipeg told CBC News the apartment complex "met the conditions and requirements" of the Mitigate Unsafe Conditions Order, and had been issued a full occupancy permit allowing tenants to return. 

"Nobody ever thought we would get back there … nobody ever thought we would go back home," said Debby Ross, a Birchwood Terrace tenant who has been living in a hotel room for the past seven months. "It's been one hell of a journey."

Ross and her two cats are moving back to Birchwood Terrace. She has been living at the building complex for the last five years, where she says complete strangers have become part of her family. 

"There's something about that place that I love … Birchwood's not taking that away from us," she said. 

But despite being one step closer to going back to her home, she is concerned about the state her apartment has been left in while the building has undergone construction work.

"I'm choosing to move back, that's my home, but to go back, leave it as I had it," Ross said. 

Concerns about timeline

Ladco Company told tenants in the email that they would be contacted individually to arrange the moving day and meet with the resident manager to inspect the units, complete a conditions report and "do anything else" prior to settling back into the apartments, including signing lease agreements and paying for a first-month rent deposit. 

The company said it is "striving to quicken the move-in process," but Ross is concerned about how the timing will work. 

The province has been footing the bill for displaced tenants staying at hotels. Ross said that funding has to be renewed at the end of every month, and with no date confirmed to go back home, she is worried she may not have somewhere to stay after Dec. 31.

A woman on a blue sweater is besides a Christmas tree.
Joyce Hilborn, a displaced resident from Birchwood Terrace, is concerned about who will cover any other extensions at hotels beyond Dec. 31, as residents might need more than two weeks to move back into their apartments. (Felisha Adam/CBC)

"We don't know who's going to be covering, you know, any other extensions … that's up in the air right now and leaving, you know, a lot of people quite anxious," said Joyce Hilborn, another resident from Birchwood Terrace who has been living in a hotel room since the evacuation. 

CBC News reached out to Ladco Company for comment but hasn't heard back. 

A spokesperson for the province said the government "will continue to support tenants as they work with Ladco to complete their move back home" but wasn't specific about whether they will continue paying for their stay in hotel rooms. 

'I couldn't see myself going back': former tenant

Judith Stanley, who lived at the apartment complex for 10 years, is not going back into her unit. 

She said the building's structural stability is only one of the infrastructural problems. Water pipes have burst inside the complex, leading to flooding and the presence of mould.

After being uninhabited for months, Stanley said the building is also now dealing with a mice infestation problem. 

A building sign reading Birchwood Terrace
Judith Stanley, who lived at the apartment complex for 10 years, said she is not going back into her unit out of her own safety, due other infrastructure problems affecting the building. (Gary Solilak/CBC)

"I wouldn't feel safe," she said. "I'm shocked that people are going back … I couldn't see myself going back." 

Relocating to a new apartment has also dealt the senior on fixed income a financial blow to re-establish her life, going from $1,250 to $2,100 in monthly rent. 

Stanley has also invested thousands of dollars in a damage deposit for her two dogs at the new apartment, moving costs and purchasing clothes and furniture stolen from a truck outside the building during the evacuation — expenses covered out of her own pocket. 

"I'm usually a complete Christmas person … this year, I feel like I'm dead inside the apartment I have now," she said." It's not home. It's just somewhere I go."

Evacuated Winnipeg apartment block gets go-ahead to welcome back tenants

3 days ago
Duration 2:14
After more than seven months, the roughly 250 people forced out of Birchwood Terrace apartment complex on Portage Avenue may soon be back in their homes. The City of Winnipeg on Tuesday issued an occupancy permit for the building, which had been vacant since serious structural problems were discovered in the spring.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Santiago Arias Orozco is a journalist with CBC Manitoba currently based in Winnipeg. He previously worked for CBC Toronto and the Toronto Star. You can reach him at santiago.arias.orozco@cbc.ca.

With files from Felisha Adam