Separatists release potential Alberta referendum question, expect Danielle Smith to join cause
Jason Markusoff | CBC News | Posted: May 12, 2025 6:45 PM | Last Updated: 2 hours ago
Alberta Prosperity Project says premier should hold referendum in 2025, with UCP base heavily pro-secession
An Alberta separatist group released on Monday a referendum question on independence from Canada that it will petition to get in front of provincial voters — but only once it has garnered support from 600,000 Albertans.
That's more than triple the number of signatures the Alberta Prosperity Project (APP) would need under a new United Conservative Party government bill that makes it much easier to force a referendum on the ballot.
The group also said it would push Premier Danielle Smith to allow a separation referendum later in 2025, instead of next year as she's suggested. They said a critical mass of separatist UCP members can persuade the premier to fast-track the referendum — and to join their cause as well.
At a news conference, APP lawyer Jeffrey Rath pulled a blue provincial flag off an easel to reveal the independence referendum question: "Do you agree that the province shall become a sovereign country and cease to be a province of Canada?"
He touted this ballot question as far clearer than the one Quebec put forth in its 1995 secession referendum.
"This is as serious as a heart attack," Rath said. "And this is what Albertans expect."
The pitch
In the face of economic experts warning that major problems and uncertainty would hit a five-million-person province going it alone, Rath and his fellow separatists painted an optimistic picture of separation.
They depicted an independent Alberta with no regulations from Ottawa or eastern Canadian interests, lower provincial taxes plus no federal taxes.
They suggested oil and gas development would double within five years, multiple new pipelines would extend into the United States, and residents of a breakaway Alberta republic would still keep their Canadian passports and Canada Pension Plan entitlements. (There have been no such guarantees from Ottawa, but this is the separatists' expectation of what a deal with Canada would entail.)
The group said it wouldn't launch a citizens' initiative petition until it had 600,000 registered supporters, instead of the 177,000 soon to be legally required. They said this would bring their movement closer to the much higher number of votes they'd need to win on a secession referendum.
According to an Angus Reid Institute poll released last week, 19 per cent of Albertans would definitely vote to leave Canada, while another 17 per cent say they lean in that direction. More than half of respondents said they would definitely vote to stay in Canada.
Smith declined to discuss APP's strategy when asked about it Monday at an unrelated news conference, insisting it's premature to say what will come out of a petition drive.
"Having people sign up on a website saying that they will ultimately sign a petition is one thing," Smith said. "Getting the physical signatures signed up is another. That's why we have to wait for the process to play out."
The premier reiterated that she supports Alberta staying in Canada.
"It's my job to see if we can get a new deal with Ottawa so that I can convince more Albertans to feel the same," the premier told reporters.
She has made several demands of Prime Minister Mark Carney to give Alberta a better deal in confederation — to drop many federal energy and climate policies, and overhaul the federal transfer system to give more money to her province within the next six months.
On Monday, she announced plans to unilaterally freeze Alberta's industrial carbon tax at this year's level of $100 per tonne, rather than raising it gradually to $170 per tonne by 2030 that Ottawa and the provincial government had long agreed to.
Rath said his separatist movement won't be swayed by "whatever little box of chocolates" Carney brings to the negotiation table.
Interest in Alberta independence appears to have swelled since Carney's Liberals were re-elected to a fourth straight term last month, while voters in the province overwhelmingly chose the Conservatives once again.
Smith has said she understands separatists' mindset after a decade of Liberal climate policies that she argues target Alberta's wealth-producing oil and sector. She's said if separatists force a referendum, she'll schedule it for 2026.
But the APP leaders expressed confidence they can reach 600,000 registered supporters on their website by the end of June — they're at 240,000 now, they say — and want to put their question to voters this October or November. They noted that the Angus Reid poll showed that 65 per cent of UCP supporters would definitely vote to secede, or lean that way.
"Perhaps when Danielle wakes up and realizes that her base is almost unanimous behind the idea of Alberta independence, she might have to get a different idea on the timing," Rath said at his group's update.
Mitch Sylvestre, APP's chief executive, is also the president of a northeast Alberta UCP riding association that hosted the premier and hundreds of party members at a fundraiser in the town of Bonnyville last week. He said the room appeared to be "99.9 per cent" in favour of separatism.
According to a video recording of the event posted online, Sylvestre posed the group's proposed referendum question to Smith. The premier didn't answer, but instead responded by laughing and asking her own question to the crowd: "How many of you believe that we can negotiate — I'm looking for the yesses — for a strong and sovereign Alberta within a united Canada."
While she received a smattering of applause, her question was audibly jeered by some in the crowd. "I got a few [yesses]," she replied. "I'll take it where I can. I'm going to try, guys."
Sylvestre said he's willing to hold Smith to her word that she'll give the federal Liberals six months to make concessions, before hoping she'll join the separatist cause that so many UCP activists back.
"Then after that she's going to decide if she doesn't come over to our side, well there's going be a problem," Sylvestre said.
He was asked what he meant by that, and if that was a reference to former premier Jason Kenney, who was ousted by United Conservatives for not following grassroots members' wishes on vaccine policies and liberty restrictions during the COVID pandemic.
"I don't think we have to go down the Jason Kenney path," Sylvestre replied. "I think Danielle is smarter than Jason Kenney, and I think she'll figure that all out on her own."
Dennis Modry, another APP leader, added: "As the Alberta Prosperity Project registrants grow to several hundred thousand, at some point she will very likely get in front of this train."
Aside from needing to amass all the petition signatures and votes to make separation a reality, the path toward an independent Alberta would be pocked with questions, from constitutional challenges and Indigenous land rights to the economic realities.
APP proponents pitched it as an unvarnished good. "When you take away all of the federal regulation, the ability of Alberta businesses to be profitable is going to go through the ceiling," Rath said Monday, adding he foresaw five new oil and gas pipelines south through Montana alone.
They are only pitching a "best-case scenario," said Carlos Freire-Gibb, a business professor at MacEwan University in Edmonton who has researched the risks in jurisdictions with separatist movements.
There will be no guarantees there's an advantageous, barrier-free trade deal with the rest of Canada or with the United States, he said.
He foresees heavy instability, even before the separation push gets a referendum to voters.
"I don't think any company will invest in a region where we don't know what's going to happen, what's going to be the legal status," Freire-Gibb told CBC News in an interview.
"The rosy scenario could happen, but most likely it will be very bad for Alberta, but it will also be very bad for Canada."