City hall security gates cost $150K, went up before review wrapped
CBC News | Posted: March 1, 2020 9:00 AM | Last Updated: March 1, 2020
Security office says it could have consulted and communicated better
New security gates at Ottawa City Hall that have caused a stir cost just under $150,000 and were installed before a wider security review was finished, the city has revealed.
Two new security checkpoints, with gates that don't include metal detectors, were installed in the final days of 2019 outside the main council chambers for the first meetings of the new year.
Some councillors were upset they went up without a vote, while advocacy groups worried the gates and other security upgrades would discourage participation in meetings and quell protest.
- Protest signs, outside food banned as city boosts council security
- 'Jazz hands,' small signs still permitted at council
Councillors Shawn Menard and Mathieu Fleury asked the city's emergency and protective services department for more information last month about the decision to add the gates, including what the cost was and who was consulted.
In a reply posted online Thursday as part of the agenda for the next finance and economic development committee (FEDCO) meeting, the city said the gates cost $149,109.55 — with all but about $2,000 going toward the purchase and installation.
The installation was approved by emergency and protective services senior managers who have the power from a city bylaw — officially known as "delegated authority" — to make corporate security decisions.
As it's done before, the city pointed to an corporate security audit conducted in April 2019.
The city's auditor general recommended management review its guidelines for high-profile meetings — although he never specifically mentioned checkpoints outside the council chamber.
The audit said staff studied what other similar cities had done, noting that Toronto, Winnipeg, Calgary and Edmonton all either check bags, run guests through metal detectors, or both.
The city said there would be some public consultation as staff develop a new corporate security policy, which will go to council later this year for approval.
"Staff recognizes that consulting with elected officials, along with having a more detailed communication plan, could have improved the implementation of the most recent security measures for council chambers," the city's response said.
6 knives, 2 complaints
As justification for the enhanced security measures, the city's response pointed to the 2014 attacks at the National War Memorial and Parliament Hill, during which the first shots were fired about one kilometre from city hall.
It also mentioned an unspecified "national security threat" that drew Ottawa police and RCMP to the building, as well as a few protests around council.
Six knives have been confiscated at the new checkpoints since they went up on Jan. 23, the city noted. There have also been two formal complaints about the changes.
The responses will be part of the next FEDCO meeting on March 9.