Atlantic puffins listed as endangered species in Europe

Climate change to blame and could soon affect puffins in Maine

Media | Puffin Patrol – Climate Change

Caption: null

Puffins in some parts of the Atlantic are fighting a battle beyond their control.
European puffin populations were listed as endangered(external link) on the International Union for the Conservation of Nature's Red List of Threatened Species in October. The oceanic shifts caused by climate change are cited as a key threat in the recent listing.
In Europe, many Atlantic puffin populations, especially those that breed in Iceland and Norway, are in decline.
That's a striking contrast to the status of Atlantic puffins that breed in Newfoundland, where the seabirds seem to be doing just fine.
Why this drastic difference between Europe and Newfoundland?
The issue in Europe seems to be the puffins' supply of fish. Northeastern Atlantic waters have warmed, says Greg Robertson, a research scientist with Environment Canada, who has been tracking seabird populations for over 15 years off the Newfoundland coast.

Image | Puffins wing flap

Caption: Puffins are in decline in many parts of Europe, but are doing fine in Newfoundland. (CBC)

For seabirds, "when you have pulses of warm water coming up, in general, bad things seem to happen," Robertson says.
One of the puffin's favourite foods in European waters is the sand eel.
"If they are not there in sufficient numbers at the right time, these seabirds don't do well," says Robertson.
As the water warms, fish such as sand eels retreat to deeper waters or to areas farther away from the puffins' northern European feeding grounds, where they're hard for the puffins to find.
In Europe, human overfishing of sand eels is thought to be another problem for puffins.
Around Newfoundland, the Labrador current carries cold water from Greenland and the Arctic toward the Gulf of Maine, bringing capelin and other fish for the puffins to feed on.
"We don't get those warm water intrusions like they do in Europe and the eastern Pacific," says Robertson. "From the seabird perspective, it seems to be a little more stable. They seem to be able to get what they need."

Troubles in Maine

The puffin outlook appears less favourable farther south.
In Maine, puffins were reintroduced in the 1970s following their absence for over a century. Their return was thanks to efforts led by Stephen Kress and the Audubon Society.
Now, in the Gulf of Maine, when it gets too warm for fish like sand lance that these more southerly puffins normally eat, they're periodically forced to hunt warm water fish like butterfish. Those fish are too wide and bony for the gullets of their chicks, with sometimes tragic results — the babies may starve or choke.

Image | Puffins

Caption: Puffins eat small, cold-water fish such as sand eels in European water and capelin off the coast of Newfoundland. (CBC)

This climate change development signals "a new message from birds to people," Kress tells The Nature of Things.
As the climate continues to warm, puffin populations in Maine could decline like those in Europe.
Meanwhile, not all European puffins are in decline.
Those that breed at Skomer Island, Wales, seem to be "doing quite well," says PhD student Annette Fayet, who is studying that population with University of Oxford zoologist Tim Guilford(external link).
And in Europe, because wind and water currents move differently than they do off the east coast of North America, it's not necessarily the southern populations that are doing worse.
Iceland and Norway, both farther north than Wales, are home to 80 per cent of Europe's puffin populations. Those have "declined markedly since the early 2000s," according to the IUCN Red List of Threatened Species.

Puffin puzzles

After breeding in the thousands at their seabird condominiums — the grassy slopes of coastal islets honeycombed with their burrows — puffins take to the seas. Yet puffins that are next-door neighbours while raising their pufflings may spend the winter in vastly different places. That's the surprising picture emerging from Fayet's work.

Image | Puffins breeding

Caption: After breeding in the thousands on grassy slopes of coastal islets honeycombed with their burrows, puffins take to the seas. (CBC)

She attached geolocators to puffins during the breeding season and retrieved them the following summer to download their data. This lightweight technology marks a big improvement over previous efforts to find puffins in the winter, which required spotters in small planes that crisscrossed the Atlantic, scouring the seas.
Each geolocator, weighing just a few grams, measures and logs light levels, allowing researchers to estimate, using mathematical models that take into account day length, the approximate latitude and longitude of its wearer.
"The average accuracy of these positions is about 200 kilometres, which is quite rough," says Fayet.
But the geolocators have helped her to determine that some Welsh-breeding puffins go all the way to Newfoundland in winter. Others stay around the U.K., and many head to the Mediterranean.
"Some of these birds cover absolutely huge distances," says Fayet, "and that was quite surprising."
Knowing where the puffins spend the winter could help scientists figure out other reasons why some populations thrive while others don't.
The work of Robertson, Kress, Fayet and others is explored in Puffin Patrol(external link), the latest episode of CBC's The Nature of Things, produced by CBC in partnership with Rock Yenta Productions.
Corrections:
  • Due to an editing error, an earlier version of this story said that European puffins were listed as vulnerable on the IUCN Red List. In fact, they have been listed as endangered. November 19, 2015 5:16 PM