The Current

The Boogaard lawsuit against the NHL

The Boogaard family's wrongful death lawsuit seeks to hold the NHL responsible for Derek Boogaard's brain damage experienced over six seasons as an Enforcer.
Five months after Derek Boogaard's last fight on the ice in Ottawa for the NY Rangers in December of 2010, he was dead ... an accidental overdose of painkillers and alcohol. A posthumous examination of his brain found he suffered from a brain disease caused by blows to the head. His family's wrongful death lawsuit seeks to hold the NHL responsible for physical trauma and brain damage experienced over six seasons as an Enforcer. Today, we're asking about the wider implications for the NHL.



Panel: Bruce Dowbiggin / Paul Echlin

Stick dropped. Fists raised. Knuckles bare. That's the way many fans remember Derek Boogaard -- the powerful National Hockey League enforcer. Mr. Boogaard was found dead of an accidental overdose of prescription drugs and alcohol two years ago.

His family members have now filed a wrongful-death lawsuit against the NHL. They allege the league is responsible for brain damage Derek Boogaard sustained during on-ice fights as well as his addiction to painkillers.

Opponents knew to respect the strength of the "Boogeyman." But the New York Ranger was more than just a powerhouse.

"If I had to describe Derek Boogaard in one word, I would say: He's a kid. He was a kid that grew up and got everything he ever really dreamed of and just didn't really quite understand what that really meant." - John Branch, sports reporter for NY Times

John Branch is a sports reporter for the New York Times. Following Derek Boogaard's death, he wrote an intimate profile of the hockey player and the toll his life as an enforcer took on him emotionally and physically.

Derek Boogaard's parents are now taking on the NHL.

"The lawsuit really says: If you take a young man, and have him fight night after night ... subject him to trauma ... he's going to have pain. If you then give him enormous amounts of pills to treat that pain, and then promise his family that you're going to take care of the resulting addiction and fail to do so, you need to be accountable and responsible to that family for his loss. " - Boogaard's Family lawyer, William Gibbs.

We invited NHL deputy commissioner Bill Daly on the show. He declined, but offered this statement:

"We are not aware of any Complaint having been filed and have not received service of one. As with any litigation, we will handle it in the ordinary course and will have no comment."

With more on what the possible consequences of this lawsuit for the NHL -- and for the game of hockey -- we were joined by two guests.

Bruce Dowbiggin is a sports journalist and author of The Meaning of Puck: How Hockey Explains Modern Canada. His new book Best Practices about the Vancouver Canucks comes out this fall. We reached him in Calgary.

And Paul Echlin is a primary care doctor and sports medicine specialist who's conducted research into hockey concussions. He works at the Elliott Sports Medicine Clinic in Burlington, Ontario, where we reached him.


This segment was produced by The Current's Idella Sturino, Vanessa Greco and Virginia Smart.

What are your thoughts on this discussion? Tweet us @thecurrentcbc. Follow us on Facebook. Or e-mail us through our website. Call us toll-free at 1 877 287 7366. And you can always write to us at PO Box 500, Station A, Toronto, M5W 1E6.



Other segments from today's show:

My Mother, the Nazi Midwife and Me

Why we need to get over our fear of bears