Are we becoming less informed in the Age of Information?
With the victory of Brexit and now Trump, some suggest the electorate is uninformed. Others say it's the media and experts who are out of touch. Are we all becoming less informed in the Age of Information?
More from this episode:
The headlines screamed "Click Me!"
"Pope Francis Shocks World, Supports Donald Trump for President"
"Wikileaks Confirms Hillary Sold Weapons to ISIS"
"Tens of Thousands of Scientists Declare Climate Change a Hoax"
Of course those weren't real news stories based on facts. But they spread like wildfire on social media.
Fake news stories about Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton dominated the news towards the end of the U.S. election campaign often outperforming real news stories and more popular than stories debunking them.
It's not like we haven't seen satirical news before. Saturday Night Live, The Onion, or CBC Radio's own This is That walk the line between poking fun at real news and being mistaken for real news.
But it seems we've entered the era of 'post-truth' so much so the Oxford Dictionary recently declared that the 'Word of the Year.'
In an attempt to counter lying sources and lying politicians, traditional media rolled out fact-checking journalism. But partisans claim someone should check the fact checkers because they're biased too.
Some lay blame on Facebook feeds and Google searches. Many say algorithms designed to filter our preferences turned our digital social existence into an echo chamber, where we don't hear any views other than those we might approve.
Others single out 'political bots' for skewing U.S. election results by automatically generating a slew of fake news headlines.
With all of the information — real and fake — competing for your attention, how do you sort through it all? Do you make an effort to look at information you might not agree with, in order to ensure you have the full picture?
Our question: "Do you think we're becoming less informed in the Age of Information?"
Guests
Mathew Ingram, senior writer at Fortune magazine
Twitter: @mathewi
Chris Kelly, Senior Producer, This Is That comedy show whose stories are sometimes mistaken as real news
Twitter: @cgkelly @CBCThisIsThat
Lydia Miljan, Associate Professor of political science at University of Windsor. Co-author of several books including: Hidden Agendas: How Journalists Influence the News and Public Policy in Canada
Twitter: @lmiljan
Links & Articles
Mentioned in the show
- Mathew Ingram: Trump's National Security Adviser Shared Fake News About Clinton
- Mathew Ingram: Here's Why Stamping Out Fake News Is a Lot Harder Than You Think
- Mathew Ingram: Here's One Reason Facebook Doesn't Want to Admit to Being a Media Company
- Mathew Ingram: Facebook Must Own Up to Being An Increasingly Powerful Media Outlet
- Chris Kelly: This Is That releases a book [NOT SATIRE]
CBC.ca
- Have we smothered the facts?: 'Post-truth' named word of the year
- Why 'post-truth' wins Oxford Dictionaries' word of the year
- The Beaverton is Canada's newest destination for fake news and political satire
- How social media skews our election perception
- Google says it will crack down on fake news sites
- Only Facebook knows how it spreads fake election news
- How could we — I — get so much so wrong? - Michael's essay
- The media keeps getting Donald Trump wrong
- The uncertain future of journalism and why it matters
- Election surprise: political fact checking doesn't work!
- Trump, Brexit based on misconceptions about race and nationality, says renowned philosopher
National Post
- 'People are definitely dumber:' Meet the fake news writer who thinks Trump is president because of him
- It's true: Google's top news link for 'final election results' goes to a fake news site with false numbers
- Leonid Bershidsky: Fake news rushes in where others fear to tread
- Mark Zuckerberg outlines how Facebook can fight fake news: Warning labels and third-party work
Globe and Mail
Toronto Star
- Donald Trump said 560 false things, total
- Donald Trump Quick Facts
- Toronto Star's Daniel Dale named breakout media star for cataloguing Trump's mistruths
- Google, Facebook adjust ad rules for fake news sites
New York Times
- How to Satirize This Election? Even the Onion Is Having Trouble
- Facebook Restores Iconic Vietnam War Photo It Censored for Nudity
- Inside Facebook's (Totally Insane, Unintentionally Gigantic, Hyperpartisan) Political-Media Machine
BBC
Wired
Atlantic
New Republic
NPR
Althouse Blog
- If you're going to make up fake stories for the internet.
- Facebook don't even try to censor fake news
- "Inside Facebook's (Totally Insane, Unintentionally Gigantic, Hyperpartisan) Political-Media Machine/How a strange new class of media outlet has arisen to take over our news feeds."