Thunder Bay·In Depth

Grassy Narrows marks 20 years of the blockade protecting its land from logging

The Treaty 3 First Nation of Grassy Narrows gathered to celebrate 20 years of a blockade that has stopped clear-cut logging in their traditional territory in northwestern Ontario. But as they celebrate, they worry that logging and mining may resume on the lands they call home.

Community members say the blockade is as urgent now as it was in 2000s

A man stands with his arms crossed in front of a snow covered road, with forest on either side.
Robert Williamson stands at the site of the Grassy Narrows blockade as he and community members from the First Nation celebrated the 20th anniversary of their blockade to stop clear-cut logging in their traditional territory. (Allan Lissner/freegrassy.net)

In early December 2022, community members from Grassy Narrows (also known as Asubpeeschoseewagong) braved winter temperatures to gather around a sacred fire and feast in celebration.

They were marking 20 years of that sacred fire burning — 20 years of a blockade to prevent clear-cut logging and mining from happening in their traditional territories.

It's a blockade that's needed as urgently now as it was in the 2000s, say community members from the Ojibway First Nation in northwestern Ontario.

"We have to keep fighting. We have to keep saying no. We have to keep protecting this place," said Chrissy Isaacs, one of the original blockaders.

A man beats on a hand drum on the porch of a cabin in the winter.
Mike Fobister, a member of Grassy Narrows's Land Protection Team, beats a hand drum on the porch of a permanent cabin set up at the Slant Lake blockade site, first erected in December 2002. Fobister was part of the 20th anniversary celebrations on Dec. 2, 2022. (Allan Lissner/FreeGrassy.net)

Land that the First Nation considers part of its Indigenous protected area could be reopened to logging as Ontario's Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry (MNRF) prepares a new 10-year forest management plan in the Whiskey Jack Forest, according to a ministry spokesperson.

There are also about 3,200 mining claims in the area over which Grassy Narrows is asserting jurisdiction, the spokesperson added in a statement.

As the Treaty 3 First Nation continues to assert its sovereignty and tries to prevent resource extraction from occurring, community members shared with CBC News their memories of the early blockade days and how the significance of their work has changed.

A growing resistance

For years, people in Grassy Narrows were concerned about the amount of logging happening in the Whiskey Jack Forest that surrounded their community.

"We had lived with the logging industry our whole lives, you know, driving behind logging trucks," recalled Judy Da Silva, a longtime spokesperson for the First Nation.

In the late 1990s, the logging got faster and closer to the community, Da Silva said.

A scene of an area that was affected by clear-cut logging.
This image, taken in 2006, shows one of the areas in the Whiskey Jack Forest within the lands over which Grassy Narrows has claimed jurisdiction, which had been clear cut. (Submitted by David Sone)

"We had been hearing from the hunters and the trappers that, you know, one weekend their hunting grounds were there, and then the following weekend the hunting grounds would be logged over and they'd have no more trap line."

As forest management documents showed plans to continue cutting right around Grassy Narrows, women from the First Nation began organizing, Da Silva said. They sent letters to politicians, built relationships with like-minded activist groups across the world, and went into their classrooms to educate younger generations about their work.

"It had been a buildup of us getting educated about the logging industry, how they're destroying our habitat, how we're getting poisoned by them with mercury. It just went on and on," Da Silva told CBC News in an interview from the blockade site.

A late night catalyst

The blockade itself, which continues to this day, all started one dark night in the winter of 2002, with two sisters on a drive.

"We were just having conversations about what the future is going to be like … talking about our kids, how they might miss out on being able to hunt and pick berries and have that knowledge of the land," Isaacs said.

"As we're talking about that, a big logging truck went by and then I remember saying we have to stop that, and she said, 'OK, let's do it.'"

Chrissy Isaacs of Asubpeeschoseewagong (Grassy Narrows) First Nation says many families in northwestern Ontario have similar stories of racism, mistreatment or no treatment at the hospital in Kenora. (Marc Doucette/CBC)

It was a spur-of-the-moment decision; Isaacs and her sister picked up a third person with a chainsaw and they went out right then to start the blockade, cutting down trees to block the road.

Da Silva remembers the stories from that night.

"They tried to cut trees down to block the road, and they said the first one went backwards, so it didn't go on the road. The second one went halfway on the road, but then their car broke down," she said.

A young child holds up a sign that says "stop the logging now" during a protest.
A child from Grassy Narrows carries a sign during a protest in Winnipeg in this archival photo from the late 2000s. It was part of the Treaty 3 First Nation's efforts, which escalated in 2002 when they erected a blockade to stop clear-cut logging in their traditional territory. (Jon Schledewitz/freegrassy.net)

Their dad, Robert Williamson, drove out to help his daughters, Da Silva said.

"When everybody went home," Williamson was there "all alone and he stopped one of the first logging trucks by himself," she added.

The next day, Dec. 2, students from the local school and other community members heard about the blockade and came down to block the roads, and prevent logging trucks from going into their territory.

Roving blockades

There are video recordings of those early days, in a documentary called As Long as the Rivers Flow, by David Clement and Thunder Bay Indymedia, that shows interactions between loggers, police officers and blockaders.

Photos and video show children lying on the roads, standing in front of trucks, holding up signs to turn away the loggers.

WATCH | People from Grassy Narrows turn back logging trucks

Grassy Narrows community members establish blockade in 2002

2 years ago
Duration 2:23
Archival video shows an encounter during the early days of the blockade in December 2002 between young activists from Grassy Narrows First Nation, a forestry contractor, and an officer with the Ontario Provincial Police. The video was shot by David Clement and Thunder Bay Indymedia as part of their documentary As Long as the Rivers Flow.

At first, the blockade site was just the sacred fire, chairs and a tarp to block the wind, Da Silva said, with some temporary structures going up over the coming months and years. But as time went on, Da Silva said the First Nation learned logging trucks started using different roads throughout the territory.

Barbara Fobister remembers she and a few others started doing "roving blockades," where they would patrol different forestry roads, looking for new cuts and logging camps.

On one particular snowy evening, Fobister said she, her sister and a couple others — mostly women — were going out to a new logging camp to deliver eviction notices.

"We were kind of scared, like [mostly] women going to the campsite," she said.

An aerial photo shows a yellow arrow with the words "native land rights now" pointing up the steps at Queen's Park in Toronto, Ontario.
As part of the efforts by Grassy Narrows First Nation to stop clear-cut logging on their lands, they went to Queen's Park in Toronto, as seen in this aerial photo from the 2000s, to call for recognition of their land rights. (Submitted by David Sone)

They arrived and knocked on the trailer door. When it opened, Fobister said the view was a bit of a surprise.

"The loggers were all sitting there watching hockey, and they were all in their long johns," she laughed. "It kind of eased the fear in us, like it kind of was a comical sight … we found it funny, like these loggers that we were so scared of are sitting around in their pyjamas."

Fobister said they served the loggers with their eviction notice — "signed with an X, just like how the treaties were signed" — and they told them to vacate within 24 hours. The next day, she said they were gone.

Fobister's daughter, Melissa Bunting, had a newborn baby at the time, and laughs at memories of her mom.

"I wasn't out there with them, but I do remember her sometimes getting phone calls, and she'd be like, 'oh my gosh, really? OK, OK, I'll be there. I got to go.' And she would just jump up and leave."

Blockade led to no-harvest area designation

As the blockade continued on and people from Grassy Narrows continued to apply political pressure, the First Nation gained commitments from government and pulp and paper companies.

In 2008, newsprint company Abitibi-Consolidated ended its logging operations in the Whiskey Jack Forest area.

Almost a decade later, in 2017, the MNRF formally designated a no-harvest zone that encompassed 76 per cent of the forest under the 2012-2022 provincial forest management plan. The moratorium on logging in that area was then extended until 2024, when a new plan currently under development is expected to come into effect.

More recently, in October 2022, the president of Weyerhaueser, which owns a large, regional mill in the area, sent a letter to Grassy Narrows saying they will honour the First Nation's no-harvest zone, and "commits to working with the Grassy Narrows Land Protection team, under the guidance of Chief and Council, prior to sourcing wood from within Grassy Narrows traditional territory."

Blockade's given Grassy Narrows 'a sense of identity'

Over the years, Bunting said, the actual blockade site has changed.

Gone are the temporary structures. In their place are permanent sleeping quarters, a Sun Dance ground, and a wigwam that functions as a land-based education space.

"It almost feels like a home now. When you go there … you feel comfortable. It's a place where we all gather now for celebrations," Bunting said.

Da Silva added the area has become "way more than just a blockade."

People from Grassy Narrows First Nation, pictured in this CBC photo, say the blockade has given them a sense of cultural identity and helped them reconnect to their traditional territory. (Marc Doucette/CBC)

"It's a cultural revitalization … there's these young people that never saw the action of the blockade, but they feel the history of it," she said.

Then a new mother, Isaacs is now a grandmother to several little ones.

"When I was a child, I don't remember really any cultural things going on, or I don't remember being taught about who I was. But now there's a sense of identity because of the blockade," she said.

"That's the whole purpose for me … to make sure there's something here for my kids and my grandkids — a place of finding ourselves, getting connected to the land again."

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Logan Turner

Journalist

Logan Turner is a former journalist for CBC News based in Thunder Bay, Ont.