Saskatoon

Canadian father struggling to get his baby into the country

The baby’s residency applications have been rejected twice. The first one was rejected because the couple didn't include necessary consent forms in the application, and it's been downhill since then.

Multiple residency applications remain in limbo

A man can be seen holding a baby in his arms with a woman standing next to him.
Lincoln Sekkappan, left, and Kamalam Elangovan are struggling to get their baby daughter to Canada. (Submitted by Lincoln Sekkappan)

Lincoln Sekkappan has been sitting in front of his computer in Regina every day for months anxiously waiting for his 11-month old daughter's Canadian residency application to be approved.

Sekkappan is a Canadian citizen. His wife Kamalam Elangovan has permanent residency in Canada. Unfortunately for them, Elangovan gave birth to their daughter Avira Mutho in India while on a trip visiting her parents.

Nearly a year later, the couple is still living worlds apart.

"Right now my wife can come to Canada because she is a permanent resident. I am a Canadian citizen, I can go and come. But my kid doesn't have anything," Sekkappan said. "So as a result the only option we have is we can abandon our kid in India like an orphan."

Two of the baby's residency applications have been rejected. The first one was rejected because the couple didn't include necessary consent forms in the application, and it's been downhill since then.

"We got this child after four and a half years of our marriage, and being separated is difficult. We didn't think that the process was going to be that long," Elangovan said.

A woman can be seen wearing a red and blue striped jacket next to a man in a green and grey striped shirt.
Lincoln Sekkappan and Kamalam Elangovan have been waiting for months for their 11-month-old daughter's residency application to come through. (Submitted by Lincoln Sekkappan)

She said it's mentally exhausting to be alone in India with their daughter and without the support of her husband.

After the first rejection, Sekkappan uploaded the missing documents and resubmitted the application. But it was rejected again for not having the consent forms, which Sekkappan said are clearly included in the file.

"Whatever document they are saying is missing, it's already there in that application. They are not even going through that properly. And the second thing is like there is no transparency in their process."

A man and a woman can be seen standing on a boat in the water. They are both wearing denim clothing.
The couple is frustrated that their baby daughter's residency application seems stuck in the system. (Submitted by Lincoln Sekkappan)

Sekkappan said he called the immigration department's customer line for help, and was told to submit a brand new application in addition to the one he already submitted.

"They are saying the second application cannot be accepted because the previous application is active. But technically that application is not moving anywhere. The second one is not moving anywhere. So then I totally gave up," he said.

WATCH | Canadian citizen struggling to get his baby into Canada: 

Canadian citizen struggling to get his baby into Canada

1 year ago
Duration 2:25
A Canadian father is struggling to get his baby into Canada. He's had multiple rejections on his daughter's residency applications, because of a mistake he made at the beginning of the process.

Sekkappan said he received a letter from the immigration department saying both his applications have been rejected, but on the online portal the initial application still says "submitted."

He said he's currently living with his friends in Regina because he does not want to be alone with his thoughts. He said  he has lost trust in the immigration process and his mental health is being affected negatively.

"My kid started walking, talking, blabbering and all that stuff, but I don't have those fortunate moments to share with them. I don't know what to say exactly, my feelings at times hurt too much," Sekkappan said.

A man and a woman can be seen standing next to each other, they are both wearing  blue clothes.
The couple has had multiple rejections for their baby daughter's residency applications. They say they have taken all the right steps and submitted all the documents. (Submitted by Lincoln Sekkappan)

Immigration lawyer Chris Veeman said multiple factors are at play here.

First, the parents did not follow instructions perfectly, which led to the initial rejection, and now the immigration department can't seem to explain the next steps needed for approval.

Veeman said immigration is not an easy process, and that human error and now technical troubles are creating a lot of chaos. He said the family may need professional help to finalize the application.

"I think the key is to figure out exactly what's going on with that resubmitted [permanent residency] application, because it does seem like it's in the system. If they can get confirmation that that is the case, despite the letter that they got that it's going to be processed, that's probably the first thing."

He said that Sekkappan has been interacting a lot with immigration authorities and while that might be helpful sometimes, other times it can be counterproductive. He suggested having some patience might be a better approach.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Aishwarya Dudha is a reporter for CBC Saskatchewan based in Saskatoon. She specializes in immigration, justice and cultural issues and elevating voices of vulnerable people. She has previously worked for CBC News Network and Global News. You can email her at aishwarya.dudha@cbc.ca