Nova Scotia

Houston no longer wedded to fixed election date his government set in 2021

Tim Houston is no longer committed to the fixed election date he championed and vigorously defended in 2021. Speaking to reporters Wednesday, the premier suggested Nova Scotians could go to the polls earlier than July 15, 2025.

'I think it's really important that people have their say,' says premier

Man with a light grey shirt and mauve coloured tie sits at a desk with a microphone and glass of water in front of him.
On Wednesday, Premier Tim Houston suggested the fixed election date might be an impediment to the wishes of Nova Scotians. (Jean Laroche/CBC)

Tim Houston is no longer committed to the fixed election date he championed and his party passed as its first law in government.

On Wednesday, asked by a reporter when the next provincial election would be, the premier responded, "The election will be when the election is."

"At some point in time, it'll be time to go to the people and ask them how they want to move the province forward," said Houston. "When that time is here, there'll be an election."

When he'd been asked previously, Houston had pointed to the fixed election date of July 15, 2025.

Pressed Wednesday on whether a vote could be held before that date, Houston replied, "It could be."

'Determined on the circumstances' 

"It'll be determined on the circumstances," he said. "I think it's really important that people have their say."

Later he went a step further, suggesting the fixed election date might be an impediment to the wishes of Nova Scotians.

"When it becomes time for the people to have their say, I think it would be pretty selfish for me to say, 'No, you have to wait because it doesn't suit the political legislation that was passed,'" said Houston.

That's a far cry from what the premier told the House on Oct. 14, 2021 — the day he led off debate on Bill 1, the Elections Act.

"We're listening to Nova Scotians and we are keeping a campaign commitment that we made," Houston said during second reading of the proposed law. "The amendments to the Elections Act will establish fixed provincial general election dates every four years in this province.

"That's a good thing. It will bring predictability to our elections. And our elections, of course, are the cornerstone of our democracy."

Elections N.S. recommended fixed dates

During his speech, Houston chided the opposition parties for failing to act on repeat recommendations put forward by Elections Nova Scotia for a fixed election date.

"Former governments have chosen not to act upon the request of Elections Nova Scotia, but this government won't look the other way," he said at the time. "We're going to walk the walk."

The opposition parties later tried to slow down passage of the bill after it was roundly criticized by those who spoke at the law amendments committee. Undeterred by those opinions and the delay tactics used by opposition members, the government used its majority to turn the bill into law. 

A man in a suit and tie stands in front of microphones while people stand to either side of him.
Liberal Leader Zach Churchill questioned why Houston appears to be backtracking on the first law the PCs passed as a government. (Michael Gorman/CBC)

Liberal Leader Zach Churchill called the premier's suggestion Wednesday that voters will decide the next election date "weird" and "ridiculous."

"It was nonsensical," said Churchill. "The fact is that he controls when an election happens."

"His first law that he passed in Nova Scotia was a fixed election date," he continued. "So if that is a piece of legislation that he doesn't come through on, what are we to trust with what he says?"

A woman stands in front of microphones while other people stand around her.
NDP Leader Claudia Chender said if Houston calls for an early election, it will be to benefit himself. (Michael Gorman/CBC)

NDP Leader Claudia Chender called Houston's assertions that he would call an election at the behest of Nova Scotians "disingenuous." 

"When the premier decides to go to the polls will have nothing to do with when Nova Scotians should have a voice, and everything to do with when he thinks he can win," said Chender.

Speculation about a possible early election call has been heating up as a result of a flurry of nomination meetings by the PC Party of Nova Scotia.

WATCH | Former politican not surprised premier no longer committed to fixed election dates:

Why have fixed election dates? N.S. politico weighs in

6 months ago
Duration 5:33
Jo-Ann Roberts is a former interim leader of the Green Party of Canada and an author who is writing a book — in part — about fixed election dates. Watch her conversation with Tom Murphy.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Jean Laroche

Reporter

Jean Laroche has been a CBC reporter since 1987. He's been covering Nova Scotia politics since 1995 and has been at Province House longer than any sitting member.