NL

N.L. community consumed by grief after violent highway deaths of 22-year-old women

The highway deaths of two young women have left a community reeling, says a woman planning a vigil for the pair on Friday.

Community planning Friday vigil for Haley Keating and Erin Pretty

Two young women with arms around each other in a sunny field
Haley Keating, left, and Erin Pretty died after a collision on the Trans-Canada Highway earlier this month. The 71-year-old driver of the other vehicle sustained serious injuries. (Name withheld by CBC)

The violent highway deaths of two young women have left a swath of people on Newfoundland's Avalon Peninsula reeling, says a woman planning a vigil for the pair on Friday.

Haley Keating and Erin Pretty, both 22, were on a day trip to Clarenville when they collided with an SUV on the Trans-Canada Highway near Arnold's Cove on Jan. 21.

The collision killed Pretty at the scene, and Keating died days later in hospital. The 71-year-old SUV driver, who police say showed "signs of impairment," was pulled from his burning vehicle with serious injuries.

The women were widely known and loved by their Trinity South community, says Michelle Reid, a resident of nearby Spread Eagle whose daughters were friends with Pretty and Keating.

"They were two beautiful souls," Reid said.

"They were just starting out their lives. Bright, beautiful people … there's no explanation for it. It shouldn't have happened."

A woman looks down, distraught.
Michelle Reid, whose daughters grew up with Pretty and Keating, is planning a vigil to remember the pair and offer a safe space for the community to grieve. (Ted Dillon/CBC)

Reid organized a gathering Friday in Dildo to honour the women. She'd be surprised, she says, if there was a single person in the region who didn't know the pair.

"It's a tragic loss that's being felt within a community as a whole. If you've ever been to rural Newfoundland, you know how tight-knit these communities are," Reid said.

"Every single person in the community is affected by it. They're saddened. They're confused, and they're at a loss and they're having an unbearable time coping with this."

Reid, a police officer, says the general public might not have access to the same supports as first responders when they encounter a tragedy. The vigil — which will have grief counsellors present and offer a place for young people to grieve together — is an attempt to remedy that.

A woman smiles while seated and leaning on a table.
Erin Pretty died at the scene of the collision on Jan. 21. (Erin Pretty/Facebook)

"I see a bit of a gap there. I see what my daughters are going through, I see it on their faces. I see that they're not understanding. They're not able to get their heads around it and really appreciate why or how," Reid said.

"This is a safe space for anybody that needs it right now.… This tragedy is so deep-rooted as it is. I don't want anybody in our community, especially the young people, to know that there's not anybody else out there. There's so many people that are grieving. There's so many people that are trying to process this."

While the driver of the deadly collision hasn't been charged and police say they're still investigating the cause of the crash, Reid says the fact they suggested impairment may have been a factor is contributing to the community's despair.

WATCH | Terry Roberts reports on communities reeling from the loss of two young lives:

Grief and anger about highway safety after 2 best friends killed

10 months ago
Duration 2:34
An upcoming vigil will pay tribute to Erin Pretty of Dildo, Trinity Bay, and Haley Keating of Long Harbour, Placentia Bay, who were killed when their car collided head-on with an SUV driven by a 71-year-old man. The RCMP have said he showed signs of impairment, but it could be months before the results are known. The CBC’s Terry Roberts reports.

"An accident is an is an accident, but … if there's something that could have prevented a tragedy like this happening, it's going to outrage the public. And rightfully so," she said.

"Whether it is impaired or distracted driving, no matter how many charges we lay, how many convictions we get, how many families are affected, it doesn't seem to matter.… Sometimes it doesn't seem like the ripple effect really resonates with enough people to get the message out there."

A selfie of a blond woman smiling in a car
Haley Keating succumbed to her injuries in hospital. (Haley Keating/Facebook)

Reid says her daughter has had nightmares since the women's deaths, forced to play out the tragedy in her sleep.

"It was a beautiful, sunny, beautiful day. Done a bit of shopping, wanted to go for pizza," Reid said. 

"And they were heading home just the same as what any other young person would have been doing. They were living life and they were loving life."

Download our free CBC News app to sign up for push alerts for CBC Newfoundland and Labrador. Click here to visit our landing page.

With files from Terry Roberts