Despite funding hike, Ottawa still faces rights complaints over First Nations policing
Catharine Tunney | CBC News | Posted: January 13, 2018 10:00 AM | Last Updated: January 15, 2018
Public Safety will spend up to $291M over 5 years on policing in First Nations and Inuit communities
Two First Nations communities are continuing with their human rights complaints against the federal government regarding what they see as inadequate funding for their police forces, despite a recent pledge from the federal government to infuse the program with new money.
The Mushkegowuk Council, which represents seven First Nation communities covering a large area in northern Ontario, argues it receives lower-quality police services and facilities than non-Indigenous communities.
It launched a complaint after two men who were being held for intoxication burned to death at a police detachment on Kashechewan First Nation more than a decade ago.
The council's case lingers at the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal. While less formal than a court of law, the tribunal legally decides whether a person or organization has engaged in a discriminatory practice under the Canadian Human Rights Act.
On Jan. 10, Public Safety Minister Ralph Goodale announced his department will spend up to $291 million over the next five years on policing in First Nations and Inuit communities to help improve salaries, hire new officers and buy new equipment.
Grand Chief Jonathan Solomon applauded the announcement, but said he has no plans to discontinue the case.
"We are committed to securing a binding legal guarantee of adequate police resources," said Solomon.
"Two young men died in a tragic police station fire in my community because of underfunding of our police. This must not happen again."
Another First Nation, the Mashteuiatsh First Nation in Quebec, filed a Canadian Human Rights Commission complaint in 2016, arguing it couldn't even offer the minimal level of policing with the money previously provided to them. The commission investigator recommended the case be heard at the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal.
In an interview with CBC News on Monday, spokesman Dave Casavant said the band is continuing with that case while it reviews how the new funding will affect the community and police force.
Ontario waiting for more details
Through the First Nations policing program, the federal government pays about half the cost of policing for about 450 communities representing more than 420,000 Canadians, including many remote and fly-in-only areas.
On Wednesday, Goodale said he hoped the provinces and territories would also increase their contributions.
In a statement Thursday night, Ontario's Minister of Community Safety and Correctional Services Marie France Lalonde said while she's pleased to see the added funding, the province is still waiting for more details.
"We await further details and are committed to working together to address the complex challenges that exist in the realm of policing for First Nation people in Ontario," she said.
Aside from the the two human rights complaints, the federal government is facing other cases related to the First Nations policing program:
- The Naskapis Nation, in northeastern Quebec, has gone through Quebec Superior Court to argue both the federal and provincial governments have failed to negotiate in good faith.
- And the Beardy's and Okemasis First Nation in Saskatchewan has ongoing litigation alleging the RCMP has failed to fulfil its obligation, but it hasn't done anything since 2015 to continue the proceedings, said Public Safety.
The two communities have not responded to a CBC request for comment on the status of their cases.